Encrypted Messaging Apps Ranked by the FBI

We’ve all heard the tired argument, “if you’re not doing anything wrong, you have nothing to hide!” It simply doesn’t hold water. There are many reasons ordinary people take steps to safeguard their privacy, and government surveillance is near the top of that list. That’s one reason why encrypted messaging apps such as Signal, Telegram, WhatsApp, and Threema have skyrocketed in popularity recently. In January 2021, Signal became the most-downloaded free app for both Apple and Android devices, with nearly 18 million downloads in a single week — that’s a lot of users who want to keep their conversations private.

Unfortunately, privacy is a never-ending arms race. Every time individuals take steps to encrypt their data, those who wish to access it take steps to circumvent that encryption. We’ve often wondered just how much access three-letter agencies have to our sensitive information, and a recently discovered internal document from the Federal Bureau of Investigation gives us a rare glimpse at the answer.

FBI’s Ability to Access Encrypted Messaging Apps

The following document was obtained through a Freedom of Information Act (FOIA) request filed by Property of the People, a nonprofit organization that works to promote government transparency.

Encrypted-messaging-app-privacy

Since this text appears to be scanned from a degraded photocopy of the document, The Record converted it into an easy-to-read table:

AppLegal process & additional details
Apple iMessage*Message content limited.
*Subpoena: can render basic subscriber information.
*18 USC §2703(d): can render 25 days of iMessage lookups and from a target number.
*Pen Register: no capability.
*Search Warrant: can render backups of a target device; if target uses iCloud backup, the encryption keys should also be provided with content return can also acquire iMessages from iCloud returns if target has enabled Messages in iCloud.
Line*Message content limited.
*Suspect’s and/or victim’s registered information (profile image, display name, email address, phone number, LINE ID, date of registration, etc.)
*Information on usage.
*Maximum of seven days worth of specified users’ text chats (Only when E2EE has not been elected and applied and only when receiving an effective warrant; however, video, picture, files, location, phone call audio and other such data will not be disclosed).
Signal*No message content.
*Date and time a user registered.
*Last date of a user’s connectivity to the service.
Telegram*No message content.
*No contact information provided for law enforcement to pursue a court order. As per Telegram’s privacy statement, for confirmed terrorist investigations, Telegram may disclose IP and phone number to relevant authorities.
Threema*No message content.
*Hash of phone number and email address, if provided by user.
*Push Token, if push service is used.
*Public Key
*Date (no time) of Threema ID creation.
Date (no time) of last login.
Viber*No message content.
*Provides account (i.e. phone number)) registration data and IP address at time of creation.
*Message history: time, date, source number, and destination number.
WeChat*No message content.
*Accepts account preservation letters and subpoenas, but cannot provide records for accounts created in China.
*For non-China accounts, they can provide basic information (name, phone number, email, IP address), which is retained for as long as the account is active.
WhatsApp*Message content limited.
*Subpoena: can render basic subscriber records.
*Court order: Subpoena return as well as information like blocked users.
*Search warrant: Provides address book contacts and WhatsApp users who have the target in their address book contacts.
*Pen register: Sent every 15 minutes, provides source and destination for each message.
*If target is using an iPhone and iCloud backups enabled, iCloud returns may contain WhatsApp data, to include message content.
Wickr*No message content.
*Date and time account created.
*Type of device(s) app installed on.
*Date of last use.
*Number of messages.
*Number of external IDs (email addresses and phone numbers) connected to the account, bot not to plaintext external IDs themselves.
*Avatar image.
*Limited records of recent changes to account setting such as adding or suspending a device (does not include message content or routing and delivery information).
*Wickr version number.

To summarize, there’s some good news and bad news here. The FBI says it can retrieve “no message content” from six of the nine encrypted messaging apps, with the remaining three — Apple’s built-in iMessage, Line, and Facebook’s WhatsApp — only providing limited message content. From a privacy standpoint, Signal and Telegram appear to be the most secure based on this report. The former only provides date/time of registration and date of last connection; the latter may give authorities a user’s IP address and phone number if there’s evidence of terrorist activity.

Whether you’re wary of domestic government overreach, foreign nation-states, or rogue hackers trying to read your messages, it’s worthwhile to consider which encrypted messaging app you use.

More Articles on Digital Security


The Guerrilla Mentor: Timothy Lacy

Guerrilla is a Spanish word that roughly translates to “little war.” Its indication of diminutive scale doesn’t apply to the size of the battle, but rather to the size of the fighting force — a small unit up against a large opposition. In modern context, this type of imbalance is often referred to as asymmetric warfare, and its significance has been proven in countless conflicts throughout history, from the Global War on Terror to the American Civil War. Each instance has reinforced a single lesson: never underestimate the effectiveness of a small, highly motivated group of fighters.

Timothy Lacy has accrued a wealth of experience in the field of small-unit tactics. While enlisted in the U.S. Army, he served in a Scout Platoon and frequently led reconnaissance missions into enemy-controlled terrain. Later, he switched to a role in law enforcement, where he surveilled gang members and drug dealers. Lacy also spent 13 years working as a private security contractor, protecting VIPs in warzones and training indigenous militia and police forces to defend against insurgents.

Rather than settle quietly into retirement, Lacy eventually returned to his home state of Arizona and applied his skills to a new mission. In 2014, he founded Guerrilla Mentor to teach ordinary Americans about the value of small-unit tactics. Members of our staff have already attended two of his courses, Rural Reconnaissance (featured in Issue 41) and Hostile Encounters (review coming soon). Each class reinforced individual survival skills, including shooting, movement, navigation, observation, and planning. The curriculum also demonstrated the challenges of delegating tasks, communicating, and accomplishing objectives with a tight-knit group.

Despite his imposing resume, Lacy doesn’t fit the gruff soldier stereotype. He’s a soft-spoken family man whose kids showed up to play after class, and whose wife cooked a tasty meal for students at the campsite. His scholarly gray beard and friendly demeanor might even lead you to believe he’s a schoolteacher. In a manner of speaking, that’s exactly what he is — a mentor and educator for the underdog.

Timothy Lacy Guerrilla Mentor sitting on the truck bedAbove: Tim believes preparedness is a task for the whole family. His wife, Cecilia, and their children often appear at Guerrilla Mentor classes to lend a hand.

RECOIL OFFGRID: Tell us a little about your upbringing. Were survival lessons or outdoorsmanship part of your childhood?

Timothy Lacy: I was an Air Force brat until my father retired and moved us from the Phoenix area up to Show Low, Arizona. My dad was an avid outdoorsman, and we always spent our family vacations camping or hunting. After moving to the White Mountains, my brothers and I were in the forest almost every day, exploring and hunting. I spent a great deal of time with my dad stalking game and learning survival lessons. 

What led you to join the military? What was your job while you were in?

Timothy Lacy: I had always dreamed of being a soldier and serving my country. My family has always been very patriotic, and believed it was our duty to serve. All of my brothers and I served in the U.S. military. 

I enlisted in the Army as an 11B, Infantry Rifleman. I loved being a grunt — the lifestyle suited me. I discovered I had a knack for being stealthy, and so did my squad leaders. I soon found myself in the point element along with my friend Hector on nearly every patrol. 

This led me to eventually join an Infantry Scout Platoon, and I felt like I was truly in my element there. 

Timothy Lacy Guerrilla Mentora teaching studentsAbove: Showing students how to forcefully move a VIP out of a disabled vehicle at a Hostile Encounters class.

You mentioned previously that, after the military, you went into law enforcement and then private military contracting. What did you do in law enforcement and how did your military experience shape your work there? 

Timothy Lacy: After the Army, I attended the police academy and worked for two different law enforcement agencies — municipal and county. I spent the majority of my career with the Sheriff’s office where I became a Patrol Sergeant. I was on the Gang Task Force, Counter Narcotics Team as well as a law enforcement sniper. My military experience greatly shaped my work there. The discipline carried over and fit well. My squad members were probably tired of my weapon and uniform inspections, but they were, in my opinion, the best deputies in the state. The infantry, scouting, and reconnaissance skills I learned were a huge asset in assisting me throughout this time. 

Timothy Lacy Guerrilla Mentor as an officer In uniform with the Navajo County Sheriff’s OfficeAbove: In uniform with the Navajo County Sheriff’s Office

When did you make the transition into security contracting? What regions and roles did you work in?

Timothy Lacy: I made the transition from LEO to security contracting in 2006. I worked with a small European group in parts of Europe. I then went to work for DynCorp as a Police Mentor/Advisor in Afghanistan. After a year with Dyn, I got hired by Xe/USTC/ Blackwater and worked on the Afghan Border Patrol (ABP) Program. I later worked for another small company training and living with Afghan Militia/Guard Force personnel. Afterward, I was a Protective Security Specialist for IDS (a Constellis subsidiary) doing high threat protection for U.S. Department of State folks. I left Afghanistan in 2015, and continued doing short-term contracts both stateside and internationally until 2019.

Timothy Lacy Guerrilla Mentor wardak deployment 2009Above: “I’m the tall guy on the left.” Wardak Province, Afghanistan, 2009

Explain the origin of Guerrilla Mentor, and the reasoning behind the name.

Timothy Lacy: I started Guerrilla Mentor around 2014 as a small training company. I felt the need to pass on some of the knowledge and experience I had gained over the years. Guerrilla Mentor became an LLC in 2017. I chose the name based on my wartime experiences training indigenous personnel who were paramilitary. 

Timothy Lacy Guerrilla Mentor riding in a humvee 2008Above: Riding shotgun in a Humvee, Afghanistan, circa 2008

President Biden recently said, “If you wanted to think you need weapons to take on the government, you need F-15s and maybe some nuclear weapons.” Based on your experience with asymmetric warfare, what’s your response to this statement?

Timothy Lacy: I would have him study any counter-insurgency that the United States has been involved in. While we have some of the best military technology and weaponry on the planet, it isn’t getting the job done. We can see it in the resurgence of hostilities in Iraq, Afghanistan, and all over the world. F-15s and nuclear weapons are no match for weak rules of engagement and a determined opponent.

Timothy Lacy Guerrilla Mentor tora bora 2012Above: Working in Tora Bora, Afghanistan, circa 2012

We’ve seen some heated debates on social media about civilians practicing military-style tactics and wearing military-style gear. Some say it’s beneficial preparedness, and others say it’s unrealistic role-playing. What’s your take?

Timothy Lacy: I believe that every able-bodied American man and woman should not only learn these things, but I see it as their duty. It’s our duty to preserve our Republic. There are many skills that help us — not only martial skills. Gardening, medical, and the like are all very valuable. As for military-style gear, I tell prospective students that they don’t need any cool-guy gear or clothing. If you want to wear military-style gear, go for it. 

What can the average American do to prepare for the kind of widespread violent conflict we’ve seen in certain cities around the country?

TL: People need to train for it, both physically and mentally. If they have no experience, then they should seek out competent teachers. We have a large number of combat veterans with a lot of knowledge to share — you just need to find one who is willing to help. And you need to be willing to pay for good teaching. 

Timothy Lacy Guerrilla Mentor shooting from a vehicleAbove: Demonstrating how to shoot while seated in a vehicle during a Hostile Encounters class

It’s also essential to prepare mentally for violent confrontation. There are too many people who still have the mindset of “it’s not happening here in my front yard, so it’ll never happen here.” It’s past time to wake up and realize that violence can occur anywhere.

There’s a common misconception that survival is a solitary activity. How do you dispel the lone-wolf mentality and teach students to work together?

Timothy Lacy: If you’re going to attempt to be a “lone wolf,” I believe you will soon discover it’s nearly impossible to survive for long. I try to illustrate the need for a team or tribe to my students. After conducting some drills during a class, they catch on quickly that doing it alone is pretty much a myth.

Tell us about the importance of radio, spoken, and nonverbal communication for small unit tactics.

Timothy Lacy: Communication is key when working with one or more teammates. In all of my Small-Unit Tactics and Reconnaissance classes, silent hand and arm signals are taught and utilized extensively. If verbal communication is used, it’s very hushed. The ability to move and communicate silently is invaluable, as stealth is one of your greatest assets. If a team has electronic means of communication, then we combine these with other methods. In the Advanced Reconnaissance course, a field antenna is put up and regular commo checks are conducted. 

Explain the difference between a reconnaissance patrol and a combat patrol. How should gear and tactics differ for each type?

TL: Reconnaissance patrols are there to obtain information concerning the terrain, enemy, resources, and so on, and to accomplish that mission without being compromised. The standard reconnaissance team (RT) doesn’t carry enough ordinance to execute a prolonged fight, so they must rely on stealth. The equipment varies depending on the mission. For reconnaissance, you generally have tools for enhanced observation, such as spotting scopes and binoculars. You may or may not be wearing armor or any ballistic protection.

On a combat patrol, you are looking for a fight. You carry more ammunition, wear ballistic protection, and may carry a small patrol or combat pack as opposed to the larger rucksacks carried by reconnaissance patrols. 

What would you say to folks who feel like patrolling skills don’t apply to urban or suburban environments? Are any of the methods or techniques adaptable for prepared city-dwellers?

Timothy Lacy: I adhere to the philosophy that if you don’t patrol it, you don’t own it. In other words, if you don’t know what threats are in your area, it’s difficult to prepare for those threats. Whether you’re in an urban, suburban, or rural environment, it doesn’t matter.

Of course, there are differences in patrolling styles. In a city, you don’t want to walk around clothed in full camouflage wearing field gear, just as you wouldn’t conduct rural reconnaissance dressed in bright clothing. The methods of surveillance and counter-surveillance differ as well. But the core principles of patrolling and reconnaissance remain the same.

Timothy Lacy Guerrilla Mentor on deploymentAbove: Pointing out unexploded ordnance, 2010

Are there “non-combat” mental or emotional skills that you think contribute to making a good scout? 

Timothy Lacy: Absolutely. I think a good scout needs to be physically strong, but even more importantly, they should be emotionally and spiritually grounded — not given to outbursts of anger or short-fused. Scouting requires patience and a keen eye for attention to detail. When a scout starts slacking off, the consequences can be fatal, not only for the scout, but for their teammates as well. 

Let’s talk about rucksacks/bug-out bags/72-hour bags. What items should always be carried, and what items should be left at home? How much gear is too much?

Timothy Lacy: As far as bug-out bags are concerned, I keep mine packed in a smaller bag like a sling bag. I also mimic as closely as possible the loadout I carried in my go-bag while doing high-threat protection overseas. I cover the basics:

  •  Extra ammunition in magazines, usually three rifle mags and two pistol mags
  •   A good knife, fixed blade or folder, and a multi-tool
  •  At least one civilian smoke grenade
  •   Trauma kit
  •   Signals kit containing a section of VS-17 [high-visibility] panel, Rite in the Rain notepad and pen, infrared strobe, signal mirror, and permanent marker
  •  At least one bottle of water, plus some food (usually Clif bars or something similar)
  •   An emergency Mylar blanket for shelter

My 72-hour pack alternates depending on what I’m doing. In town, it’s a civilian backpack that blends in well; in the woods, it’s a medium ALICE pack or a Crossfire DG3. I carry the essentials for security, shelter, medical, signals, food, and water. I try to keep it as light as possible, depending on the season. 

I just finished an Advanced Reconnaissance Course that ran from Friday to Sunday where I carried a three-liter CamelBak, poncho liner, Gore-Tex bivvy bag, Therma-Rest sleeping pad, extra socks, underwear and T-shirts, grid fleece top, fleece cap, binoculars, night vision scope, four stripped-down MREs, cordage, small spade, hygiene kit, and a field antenna.

All of this was packed inside of a USGI large ALICE pack. 

Timothy Lacy Guerrilla Mentor gear loadoutAbove: Tim’s Gear Loadout:

  • Mayflower SCARAB plate carrier with a Paraclete dual M4 magazine pouch, TYR Tactical triple M4/pistol magazine pouch, and SureFire flashlight in a HSGI utility pouch
  • VTAC Cobra under-belt with a LBT MOLLE padded belt, two TYR Tactical pistol magazine pouches, TYR Tactical M4 magazine pouch, LBT IFAK pouch containing Dark Angel Medical trauma kit and shears, HSGI utility pouch with multi-tool, issued Uncle Mike’s Kydex holster, and a tourniquet.
  • Glock 19X
  • 10.5-inch AR pistol with DPMS lower receiver, LMT upper receiver, SB Tactical SBA3 pistol brace, Knight’s Armament Picatinny rail, Magpul Angled Fore Grip, SureFire Warcomp and Warden blast diffuser, SureFire M3 weapon light, EOTech 552 optic, MaTech backup iron sight
  • Baofeng UV-5R radio

At the Rural Recon class we covered in Issue 41, you reinforced the importance of effective camouflage. What tips do you have for camouflaging skin, clothing, and other gear?

Timothy Lacy: Camouflage is extremely important to the success of your mission. I prefer using camouflage face paint as it covers well and doesn’t interfere with breathing like some of the spandex face coverings do. As a young Infantryman, I learned to put insect repellent on my face prior to the face paint as it helped it go on much easier. I always camouflage any exposed skin and wear gloves. 

I rattle-can spray paint items to break up their outline and shape and to subdue snaps or buckles that may have become worn and shiny. I also paint my weapons to blend in as well.

Timothy Lacy Guerrilla MentorAbove: Helping a student plan his approach to a linear danger area during a Rural Reconnaissance class

As for clothing, I generally wear military pattern camouflage such as Tiger Stripe and MultiCam. Sometimes, I just wear commercial hiking clothes in earth tones like browns and greens. I often have students ask what to wear — I always tell them to get earth-toned or camouflage clothing, no black. You don’t need the latest Gucci-flage to blend in. 

I also carry and very often wear a ghillie cape and boonie hat with jute attached.

What’s one common challenge you’ve seen students experience during classes, and how have you helped them overcome it?

Timothy Lacy: There’s a belief or misconception that you need to have a ton of gear, or the latest fad in tacti-cool clothing and equipment. I demonstrate that as a “guerrilla,” you really don’t need it. If a guy shows up with a piece of equipment that doesn’t match the other “cool-guy” gear, I let him run that gear — if it functions, it ain’t wrong. Guerrilla fighters have been spanking standing armies for many years, carrying little more than the clothes on their backs, a rusted old rifle with little ammunition, and maybe a meal.

The other challenge is teaching them to work together as a team. Students are always surprised at how quickly they can learn to work together, even while conducting some of the more complex live-fire drills. 

How can preparedness duties be shared within the family? What are three survival skills you’ve learned that you think every family should be proficient in?

Timothy Lacy: Every member of the family needs to be a participant, regardless of age, or physical ability. There is always something they can help with, be it training others, gardening, handling livestock, mechanical skills, medical care, or communications/radio skills. 

I put martial skills at the top of my priority list. The ability to protect myself and my loved ones is essential to securing all other skills.

Next is the procurement and treatment of water and food. Knowing how to process wild game, grow your own food, and purify water is very important. 

Next is medical skills, from treating major trauma to the common cold. It should be on everyone’s list.

The evacuation of Kabul airport in Afghanistan is ongoing as we speak. What’s your reaction to the situation over there, and what can the average American learn from it?

Timothy Lacy: As far as the evacuation is concerned, this could have been avoided by keeping Bagram Air Base open and secured. The place is massive, and the military along with civilian air assets could move far more people rapidly than the Kabul Airport can handle. And it’s far more strategically located.

Having spent seven years in Afghanistan, I have mixed feelings about what is happening. Pretty much anyone involved in the training and mentoring of the Afghan National Army (ANA), Afghan National Police (ANP), or Afghan Border Patrol (ABP) knew this was most likely going to occur. Precious few Afghans had any concept of Afghanistan as a nation. To them, it’s all very tribal-oriented — it’s what they know. The lack of discipline and loyalty amongst the Afghan forces is also no secret, so it comes as no surprise at all to see them fold and crumble.

Timothy Lacy Guerrilla MentorAbove: Reviewing notes taken while surveilling an objective during a Rural Reconnaissance class

I do hope that many of the interpreters I worked with can make it to safety. But as I told several of them, I don’t want them to be my neighbor; I want them to stay and fight to make Afghanistan a better place.

For the average American, I would tell them to always have a plan to escape. Have contacts in place to assist you with the successful implementation of your plan. Always have the mindset that no one is coming to save you — you have to be responsible for your training and skill set.

What does the future hold for Guerrilla Mentor?

Timothy Lacy: We shall see. I’d like to continue teaching and training. I truly hope that what I teach will enable students to successfully deal with whatever life throws at them. 

[Photos by Patrick McCarthy, Tom Marshall, and Courtesy of Timothy Lacy.]


Timothy Lacy

Timothy Lacy Guerrilla Mentor ID cardAge: 58
Hometown: Show Low, Arizona
Family Status: Married with four children
Military Experience: 8 years U.S. Army 11B Infantryman
Law Enforcement Experience: 16 years
Childhood Idols: My dad
Favorite Drink: Water
Favorite Quote: Actually, it’s a Bible verse. “And I looked, and arose and said to the nobles, to the leaders, and to the rest of the people, ‘Do not be afraid of them. Remember the Lord, great and awesome, and fight for your brethren, your sons, your daughters, your wives, and your houses.’” – Nehemiah 4:14 (NKJV)

URL: facebook.com/guerillamentor
Instagram: @guerrilla.mentor


MORE SURVIVOR SPOTLIGHTS ON OFFGRID


Haley Strategic Thorax Plate Carrier: First Look

Haley Strategic is known for thoughtfully-designed products, with a focus on functionality, modularity, and efficiency. They’ve played in the tactical nylon world for a while now, with packs and bags such as their Flatpack system as well as chest rigs with their D3CR line, with small to large modular load carrying options. They’ve finally set their sights on plate carriers, with the new Haley Strategic Thorax plate carrier system. It’s a modular, lightweight system that can be configured for the mission at hand. It’s well-rounded, neither a low-vis completely slick carrier nor a full-up, heavy rig — but as a Goldilocks solution, it can be stripped down or bulked up as you wish. With plenty of Velcro, Molle, cable management, and integrated anchor and mounting points, it’s compatible with all of the company’s chest rigs on the front as well as Flatpacks on the rear, to carry as much or as little gear as desired.

We got an early production sample and bring you a first look at it here.

Haley Strategic Thorax Plate Carrier

At the core of the Haley Strategic Thorax system are the front and rear bags. They’re made of 500 denier Cordura and sized for SAPI plates, so commercial plates may or may not fit well depending on their exact dimensions and thickness. An expanding gusset accommodates plates from 0.75 to 1.125 inches in thickness. We tested plates from Midwest Armor, Velocity Systems, and Tencate — all worked great. The front bag has a velcro/Molle field at the top, which easily accepts EUD platforms, and the usual velcro at the bottom. Stretchy tweave covers straps and buckles to clip in any of Haley Strategic’s chest rigs and placards.

Haley Strategic Thorax Plate Carrier

The rear bag has a full Molle field and large lower velcro flap, and is compatible with the company’s Flatpack bags. There are also loops and anchor points on front and rear to integrate comms equipment, PTT devices, antennas, cables, and other accessories.

Haley Strategic Thorax Plate Carrier

Both bags have long flaps to retain plates securely and tabs for ease of use. On the inner side of the bags, there’s a padded chin protector and thermoform pads for cooling and comfort. In keeping with the lightweight and efficient theme, the padding only goes down the center.

Haley Strategic Thorax Plate Carrier Shoulder Straps

We installed the optional shoulder pads over the adjustable shoulder straps; they have more stretchy tweave, 0.25-inch thick hydrophobic foam, and an anchoring system so they won’t move around on you. You can also install piggyback straps for your pack if you’re rolling out heavy.

There are three main options for cinching up the Haley Strategic Thorax: traditional Velcro cummerbunds, low-profile “chicken straps,” and side entry panels for quick and easy donning and doffing.

The cummerbunds are covered in Molle, with a pocket and gusset design for side armor, cables, and so forth. They’re made of 500/1000 denier Squadron and 500 denier Cordura, with dual layer woven elastic for additional mobility while maintaining a snug fit. Cummerbunds are available in small, medium, and large sizes. There will also be accessories for armor and radios.

Haley Strategic Thorax Chicken Straps

The “chicken straps” are for those who want a very low-profile alternative to secure the plate carrier. They’re 2-inches tall with Molle and are made of 500/1000 denier Squadron. The straps are also stiffened, to strike a balance between comfort and rigidity. Chicken straps come in medium and large sizes, with optional pouches to attach armor or a radio.

Haley Strategic Thorax Plate Carrier

Haley Strategic Thorax Plate Carrier

Haley Strategic Thorax Plate Carrier

The side entry panel system makes it easy to get in and out of the Haley Strategic Thorax plate carrier, without having to lift up your placard in the front or thread yourself into the plate carrier like an Olympic high diver. It works with the cummerbunds — get one size down than you’d usually get and attach it to the rear bag. There are vertical flaps on the side entry panels, which as shown here are attached to the D3CRM Micro. Lift up the vertical flap, slap the cummerbund on the velcro field, then fold the flap back down. No muss, no fuss, and you retain as much Molle and comfort as you’d otherwise have.

Our example is configured with the D3CRM Micro chest rig, which clips into buckles on the front plate bag underneath the tweave covers and secures to the front velcro field. Of course, you can use the Micro standalone with its own harness, in either X or H-shaped designs. The D3CRM Micro is a small, handy, and flexible design, with a front zippered pouch with elastic loops and velcro inside as well as a velcro-lined area in the rear to accept various magazine pouch inserts. Haley Strategic offers a triple insert for 5.56mm magazines, a double insert for 7.62mm magazines, and a quad insert for pistol-caliber sticks. Shown here is the 5.56mm triple insert, which holds mags securely even without a retention strap. There are also two side-mounted pouches for pistol mags or other accessories. Haley Strategic also offers a variety of other pouches and sleeves, as well as Multi-Mission Hangers for additional storage below the front plate bag.

Haley Strategic Thorax Plate Carrier placard

If you don’t want to use one of Haley’s D3CR rigs, you can attach a Molle placard or a triple magazine pouch placard to the front. The mag pouch is very low-profile and also features elastic sleeves for tourniquets, det cord, or other gear.

The Haley Strategic Thorax plate carrier system is well constructed, thoughtfully designed, and holds true to the philosophy of providing functionality as efficiently as possible. And its modularity lets you kit up light or heavy, depending on your needs.

The Haley Strategic Thorax system is available in various Multicam, camouflage, and solid colorways. It’s not yet on the Haley Strategic website but will be available soon. UPDATE: here’s the link — https://haleystrategic.com/thorax. Pricing for the Thorax plate carrier system from Haley Strategic will start at $369.

URL: haleystrategic.com


MORE ON NIGHT VISION, TACTICAL GEAR, AND FIREARMS


Dark Angel Medical Training: If It Bleeds, We Can Stop It

Fans of ’80s action flicks should recognize the title of this article as a twist on Arnold Schwarzenegger’s classic line from Predator: “If it bleeds, we can kill it.” Many of you reading this have spent years practicing defensive shooting and hand-to-hand skills. In other words, you know how to make a bad guy bleed if necessary. But how much time have you spent learning how to do the opposite — to stop bleeding and save lives? Statistically, you’re far more likely to use first-aid skills than fighting skills, so allocate your time accordingly. After recognizing room for improvement in my own medical skill set, I attended a two-day Direct Action Response class from Dark Angel Medical. Our instructor, Ross Francis, is a full-time paramedic and former U.S. Navy corpsman. Francis backed many of the lessons covered in the class with stories of firsthand experience in the field.

Dark Angel Medical Training Israeli wrapAbove: Every student had the opportunity for hands-on practice applying tourniquets, packing simulated wounds with hemostatic gauze, and wrapping compression bandages — essential techniques to stop blood loss.

The Dark Angel Medical training class began with a discussion of priorities. After calling 911, your first priority is always to ensure the scene is safe before administering self-aid or aid to others. Don’t rush in and become another casualty. Next, we discussed how to assess an injured person using AVPU — check if they’re Alert and awake, only responsive to Verbal stimuli, only responsive to Pain, or totally Unresponsive. If possible, explain that you’re a trained first responder, ask for permission to help, and inquire about what happened.

After initial assessment, you can proceed in order through HABCDE areas of focus: hemorrhage, airway, breathing, circulation, “da brain,” and expose/environment. In practice, this might look like doing a blood sweep to search for bleeding, confirming that the patient’s airway is unobstructed, and checking if they’re breathing normally — if not, it’ll be hard to overlook. For circulation, check pulse, skin temperature, color, and capillary refill (pinch a fingernail). “Da Brain” means neurologic function, commonly checked by examining their pupils and asking simple questions like “what day is it?” Expose means to fully scan the victim’s body, getting them “trauma naked” if necessary; environment means to keep them covered and warm.

Any injuries revealed during the HABCDE process should be treated in that order. For hemorrhage, we practiced applying tourniquets, wound packing, and pressure dressings. For airway injuries, we placed victims in the recovery position; we also practiced inserting a nasopharyngeal airway (NPA) on a test dummy. Breathing usually means CPR, but occlusive dressings (chest seals) may be necessary if the chest cavity was punctured (sucking chest wound). For circulatory issues, stop external bleeding and watch for signs of internal bleeding. If brain injuries are suspected, the best you can do is stabilize the patient and reassure them that help is on the way. Finally, keep them warm to prevent shock after blood loss; a Mylar blanket is great for this task.

Dark Angel Medical Wound packing

Diagnoses and treatments for specific injuries were covered in detail, from gunshot wounds and eviscerations to burns and snakebites. Med kit gear selection was also covered. The class culminated in several practical exercises — each time, half the students left the classroom, and the other half were given a set of symptoms to act out. Students returned to assess and treat injuries as efficiently as possible.

If you’re not entirely confident in your first-aid skills, I highly recommend you take a class on the subject ASAP. This Direct Action Response course provided a great overview of a broad range of emergency medical topics. For more information on future Dark Angel Medical classes throughout the United States, go to darkangelmedical.com/training


More Training and Emergency Medical Skills


PAMAX Tactical LION: Civilian Flashbang Candidate

When looking at the continuum of force options available to civilians, as opposed to those used by armed professionals in law enforcement and military service, there’s a small but glaring gap in available technology. They’re known by a slew of monikers like flashbangs, NFDDs (Noise and Flash Distraction Devices), concussion grenades, stun grenades, crashers, or bangers. No matter what you call them, the operating principle is the same: a hand-thrown “grenade” type device with a short time-delay fuse that emits a loud bang and blinding flash of light for the purpose of distracting or disorienting anyone in the immediate vicinity. This allows an attacker (or defender) to expand their OODA loop by disrupting their opponent’s, buying valuable time to attack, counterattack, or escape.

The first known example we could find of a device like this is the military-issue Mark 3 (MK3) concussion/demolition grenade. The design dates back to 1918 and was effective in trench warfare. The original concept was that the MK3 could injure or disorient personnel and destroy equipment without endangering friendly forces with indiscriminate fragmentation. It was simply a lump of TNT housed in a cardboard tube with a pull-ring fuse. 

From there, the design was refined over time, with the next major milestone coming out of the UK in the late 1970s, when the so-called stun grenade first saw use by the Counterterrorist Wing of the British Special Air Service (SAS). Stun grenades typically consist of a steel body with holes cut throughout, which then has a more specialized charge of aluminum or magnesium oxide blended with something like potassium perchlorate to achieve a high-flash detonation. Newer versions of this design feature heavy-duty bodies that can be recovered and reloaded with fresh charges for repeat use. 

PAMAX Tactical LION useAbove: The PAMAX Tactical LION is designed such that even dropping it right at your feet poses no risk of frag or direct injury. Just make sure you’ve got eyes and ears on.

The issue that arises with all of these designs is that they rely on high-explosives, which are highly regulated by the BATFE. Civilian possession is extremely limited and comes with a whole host of required boxes to check, including specialized transportation and storage requirements.

These regulations, coupled with a “civilians don’t need this” perception of such devices, have made them essentially impossible to possess for anyone without agency or unit credentials. But a small company called PAMAX Tactical has come up with a solution that overcomes the legal hurdles, and has allowed us to more deeply ponder the question of “need” and application for lay persons in a defensive context. They’ve named their solution the LION BFD – Low Impact Ordnance Non-lethal, Blank Firing Device.

HOW IT WORKS

The PAMAX Tactical LION consists of a two-part design with a body and detachable base, of which there are two variants. The commercially available version uses a machined aluminum body and base. The body has a weighted, free-floating firing pin and a pull-ring safety block. Inserting the pin physically blocks the pin from impacting the blank. When the pin is pulled and the device is thrown, the floating weight is jarred on impact, causing the pin to punch the primer and detonate the device. The screw-on base has a pocket and removable adapter. The adapter has two different holes, one on each end, that can accommodate either a .209 shotgun primer or a flat-face 9mm blank (crimp-nose blanks will not work). If you remove the adapter entirely, the pocket in the base will accept a 1-inch shotgun blank. The base also has vent holes at the bottom to vent the flash and bang when the device goes off. 

PAMAX Tactical LION disassembled civilian flashbangAbove: The LION Blank Firing Device consists of a machined aluminum body with two detachable bases: aluminum for commercial use and a larger stainless steel one for law enforcement.

Building and labelling the PAMAX Tactical LION as a dedicated blank-firing device serves two purposes. First, it avoids any potential legal and liability issues from ATF, as it’s not intended to be a “grenade” of any kind. It also allows the end user a lot of flexibility to scale the intensity of detonation up and down based on use. 

PAMAX does have a second thread-on base module for the LION body, which they call the V2. The V2 doesn’t have any additional adapters but is made of stainless steel and bored a little deeper to accommodate 2-inch shotgun blanks. Neither base will accommodate full-length 2¾-inch shells to eliminate the risk of inadvertently loading a buckshot round into the LION, which could make everyone in the room have a really bad day if thrown. But at time of writing, the V2 base is currently restricted as a law-enforcement-only item. 

Our biggest concern with the V2 base being a restricted item, from a practical standpoint, is whether or not this will neuter the LION’s capabilities for commercial consumers and limit it to being a novelty item for paintball and airsoft games. But PAMAX Tactical tells us that they’re currently working with an ammo manufacturer to produce blank cartridges optimized for the LION that’ll feature charge levels and powder mixtures calculated to wring every ounce of pyrotechnic potential out of their product.  

BANG-RINSE-REPEAT

We had the chance to spend two days with the owners of PAMAX Tactical at the Deep Woods Ranch in Florida. Deep Woods is a private training facility run by former SEAL Rich Graham of Full Spectrum Warrior. Full Spectrum offers a variety of firearms training courses to civilians, law enforcement, and allied partner nations. The ranch features several shooting ranges and enclosed structures perfect for torture testing the LION. We ran tests indoors and outdoors, in barn stalls and shipping containers, with multiple different types of primers and blanks, including black powder blanks. The central Florida sugar sand was just what we needed to get the LION moist, dirty, and crusty to test the firing mechanism and safety features. 

PAMAX Tactical LIONAbove: Even when we actively packed it with wet Florida “sugar sand,” the LION functioned with 100-percent reliability.

We started with .209 primers, which produced only a token pop. Inflating a brown paper bag and popping it is probably louder. Our initial reaction was somewhere in the realm of “What’s the point of this?” until an interesting scenario was put forth: using a LION with primers to train military and law-enforcements K9s who are attached to entry teams. Primers are cheap, LIONs are reloadable, and the pop is enough to get dogs used to working around hand-thrown munitions without the cost and hearing risk to the dog associated with using full-power flash-bangs. We’ll see if someone else comes to that same conclusion, but it certainly adds to the potential versatility of this product.

Next up was testing 9mm blanks. In a confined space, it’s enough to get your attention if you’re scrolling through your phone, tuned out to the world. But it’s hardly what we’d call overwhelming. This might be a good option for paintballers and milsim reenactors who want to simulate that “bang out!” moment from Call of Duty while making entry without blowing out any eardrums. 

PAMAX Tactical LION demo

Loading the LION with 1-inch shotgun blanks is where things started to get interesting. The results weren’t enough to produce sensory overload, but unsuspecting recipients in a small room are likely to at least suffer a distraction/startle response. Is that enough capability to store one in a go-bag? We’ll get to that in a minute …

Finally, we swapped to the V2 base and ran a variety of 2-inch shotgun blanks. The author volunteered to stand inside a dark, open room with a concrete floor while the PAMAX Tactical LION was thrown in repeatedly with different loads. My level of distraction/confusion was largely nullified by context: I knew it was coming and watched the reps from PAMAX launching this thing at me. Having said that, several of the 2-inch blanks produced a flash bright enough to leave me seeing polka dots, and one of the loads produced enough overpressure that I definitely felt the “thump” of overpressure inside my rib cage when the LION detonated. Does it match up to the intensity of an actual flash-bang or stun grenade? No. But the energy disparity between blanks and high explosive charges is significant. We hope PAMAX is able to close that gap with some purpose-built loads made especially for their device. 

In terms of deploying the device, the PAMAX Tactical LION is as easy to use as the oversized safety crayons we get at chain restaurants with paper place mats, whenever we ask for chicken nuggets and apple slices. Load your blank or primer of choice into the base, screw the base onto the body, pull the safety pin, and throw. We literally packed the vent holes with wet sand before throwing and the LION never choked. We threw it on concrete floors and against every part of a vehicle we could hit: windows, windshields, hoods, wheels, and body panels. We only found one issue and one idiosyncrasy with it.

PAMAX Tactical LION demonstrationAbove: Depending on the size and type of blank used, the LION is capable of producing significant flash and moderate concussion.

Because the device requires a jolt to make the weighted firing pin assembly wobble enough to punch the primer, if the impact surface flexes or cushions the landing impact it could result in a misfire. We noticed this primarily with pockets of soft, dry sand and hoods or body panels of vehicles, which will flex or dent when hit hard enough. In these instances, giving the PAMAX Tactical LION a hard overhand throw that makes it tumble end-over-end added enough force to cause detonation, even on softer surfaces. We could not, no matter how hard we threw it, get the device to go off in our hand or in mid-air by throwing it too hard. While a side-arm lob will be plenty on a hard surface, throwing the LION end-over-end seemed to give the best chance of successful firing on the widest array of surfaces. 

The only mechanical issue we saw with the LION was the pull-pin safety. We handled several different LION bodies over the course of our testing and on all of them, the cross-pin that actually inserts into the body fit incredibly tight. On the sample LION we received for studio photos and personal testing, the pin is so tight that it actually had to be tapped in place with a hammer the first several times we removed it. Pulling it free to arm the device is the closest we’ve ever come to an active game of tug-of-war with ourselves. But PAMAX is aware of the issue and already looking at options to make the safety pin more user-friendly. (Our demo unit did eventually loosen up some.) 

We expect production models will either have a different pin or slightly larger hole machined into the body to make this process easier. In the meantime, there’s an alternate way to render the PAMAX Tactical LION safe: Simply unscrew the base from the body by one half-turn. This creates enough clearance that the pin cannot make physical contact with the primer. In our field testing, we eventually stopped using the safety pin and simply left the base unscrewed by a half-turn. When ready to deploy, just tighten the base down and throw. So, even if your safety pin requires some break-in, you don’t have to risk an AD with a blank-firing device.

PAMAX Tactical LION in vehicleAbove: With black powder blanks, the LION creates both smoke and sound diversion.

As a side note, PAMAX already has a couple of thoughtful accessories for the LION as well. They have a purpose-built Kydex holster available in MOLLE or belt-mount configurations, as well as two lanyards (polymer and braided wire) that can be looped through the safety pin and then attached to a hard point on the holster. The idea is that when you draw the LION out of the holster, the safety pin is pulled out along the way. But with the too-tight fitment we experienced, the pin (or pin hole) needs a little re-dimensioning for this to work as intended.

CONCLUSION

The burning question we had about the PAMAX Tactical LION BFD going into this evaluation was: “Is this applicable to civilians as a legitimate defensive or escape tool?”

The best answer we can come up with at this point is a hard, forehead-scrunching “maybe.”

PAMAX Tactical LION

Our experience with preproduction samples using current commercially available blanks didn’t match anything we’ve ever felt when using true explosive-cored flash-bang grenades. That’s not to say it’s not capable of causing distraction or disorientation, but conditions will have to be ideal. Power factor aside, is there even a scenario where this could cause enough of a ruckus to allow you to escape or evade a bad situation? We came up with a couple scenarios where the LION could absolutely be useful, but also figured other solutions to those same problems.

> In your vehicle, being trapped/surrounded by a growing mob of agitated protestors. Could dropping a LION out your window cause a big enough bang to disperse the crowd? Possibly. But, if mistaken for a gunshot, it could also induce armed parties in the crowd to draw their guns and return fire, escalating the situation instead of breaking it up.

> In an active-shooter scenario, could tossing a PAMAX Tactical LION opposite your planned escape route distract a shooter or draw everyone’s attention, giving you a time advantage to make your escape? Possibly. If you have time to successfully deploy it. 

> Something goes bump in the night in your living room. Could tossing a LION into the next room before making entry to confront the threat buy you some tactical advantage? Possibly. But we think you’d have to have received proper training in the specific tactics of making a room entry in conjunction with a distraction device. There’s also a possibility of disorienting yourself in the process, depending on room size, layout, and acoustics. Stealth might be your biggest ally, versus a dynamic one-man room entry — an incredibly dangerous prospect even for armed professionals. If you can evade or barricade while contacting the police, that would be the far more prudent option. 

> Same scenario, in a setting where guns aren’t available, or perhaps where a family member who is uncomfortable with guns is alone. Could the LION scare off a potential home invader? If it does, great. If it doesn’t, you just exposed yourself while escalating the adrenaline level of everyone involved.

PAMAX Tactical LION in vehicleAbove: We were able to use the LION to shatter this truck’s rear windshield but found that on flexible surfaces like safety glass and auto body panels, throwing technique was a factor for reliable detonation.

In the end, we’re a little hard-pressed to find a situation where the LION, or anything like it, would be the tool for the job in a self-defense context. But it’s a reasonable option to have accessible in a number of different scenarios. The proverbial “tool in the toolbox” to add one more capability to your emergency response spectrum. In addition to the reenactment/simulation value for those who want it, there’s also an opportunity for professional trainers to have a low-cost, low-risk way to introduce added stress to scenario-based training. 

Regardless of what you want it for, an MSRP of $249 for body and base, plus the still-very-reasonable cost of blanks and primers, makes the PAMAX LION an affordable if not niche addition to any training toolbox. 


 Sources 

PAMAX Tactical: pmtactical.com
Full Spectrum Warrior/Deep Woods Ranch: fullspectrumwarriors.com


More on Tactical Gear


Could It Happen Here? Civil War Survivors Recount Lessons Learned

Over my years as a war reporter and war crimes investigator, I am often left in awe of the individuals I meet who have survived the most unfathomable things humans do to each other. I’ve sat with people who’ve had their body parts surgically removed by aggressors, women who have been raped until they can no longer move, and children whose tiny bones have been cracked and crushed without mercy.

But for those who survive, the silver lining that shines through them is as miraculous as it is tragic. I’ve often been struck by how these ordinary people, with no formal training or skills, are forced to become extraordinary at the drop of a hat — or a bomb. The resilience to withstand the pain (both physical and psychological), to push through the darkness, and to find the thread of hope in the bundle of misery has left me both perplexed and inspired.

In documenting the lives of a few of these individuals, I hope to shine a light on just how strong the human mind can be when it comes to holding on. I hope to illuminate our ability to prepare for and push through a crisis as it dawns. And above all, I hope to instill what it means to rise above being a victim and into the terrain of survivor, and to seek inner peace long after the torment and war has subsided.

Syria

One moment, Samer Scher was one of the multitude of passionate political college students flooding the wide and dusty streets of Modamiyeh, Syria, chanting for free and fair and elections. The next moment, gunfire from forces loyal to the Bashar al-Assad regime ripped through the open air and those he knew and loved fell to the ground.

As panic and lawlessness erupted in the cool spring afternoon, just like that, Samer knew that their peaceful revolution had fallen down the rabbit hole of a violent war — a war from which he and his country would never return.

Samer Scher Civil War SyriaAbove: Samer Scher

“All we wanted was a future. Back then, if you didn’t have a link to the regime, you couldn’t get a good job; you had no future,” Scher, now 29, lamented from the safety of his small home on the outskirts of Berlin, Germany. “Animals had a better life than we did. We did not just want to receive decisions. We wanted to be part of the decision-making process.”

But from that very first barrage of bullets on the first day of their peaceful protests, the bloodshed and distrust only deepened. At any moment, anyone suspected of being part of the cadre opposing the Damascus overlords could be ripped from their homes and never seen again. Scores would be thrown into jails in the bowels of the earth, where they were subject to rape and torture. Many would be burned and blown apart, as bombs slammed into their bedrooms while they slept.

Samer, who was working as a volunteer medic at a local clinic, anxiously accepted that it was only a matter of time before the brutal enforcers came for him too. He had already seen bullets wedged into the eyes of screaming children and shrapnel searing the flesh of babies as they breathed their last breaths. He was left with the memory of a quiet conversation with a close friend, only to see that very friend shredded into pieces the very next day as a result of a shell slicing his body.

After three terrifying days of heavy fighting on the edge of his besieged hometown between the Free Syrian Army (FSA) rebels and Assad’s Army — a conscripted military — Assad’s forces breached the blockade and stormed in. It was August 22, 2012.

Tank Syrian national army near the combat zone in DamascusAbove: A Syrian National Army tank near the combat zone in Damascus, September 2013.

“I stayed in my home; there was nowhere to go,” Samer, who speaks softly with glazed eyes, continued. “It was a matter of chance — maybe the regime would come for your home, or maybe they would go for the home next door.”

Yet after nights of sleeplessness, Samer’s fogged eyes made out the shadows of soldiers peeking through the holes of his thin walls. Then, the soundtrack: gunshots cracking, footsteps, and the sounds of his front door crashing to the ground. He felt boots pelting against his limp body, splintering his bloody mouth, and then the chilling threats that they were going to shoot him.

“They were humiliating me, calling me a dog, a terrorist, insulting my family. Every one of those men — about 25 of them — were all taking a hit,” Samer said as if sifting through a graveyard of memories. “It was an unimaginable fear; I thought they would arrest me and take me to an intelligence branch.”

First, the soldiers carted Samer around the apartment building like a human shield — holding him up in case anyone opened fire as they knocked down a door. At one point, they propelled him into a bathroom, and when he turned around, he was staring down the barrel of an AK-47 at close range.

“I begged them to spare my soul, that I was just a college student,” Samer recalled.

But a bullet catapulted through his rib, another into the bottom of his arm, then another cleaved below his shoulder. Samer said the only pain he felt was the pain of fear. Facedown in a pool of crimson, he counted three more bullets entering his body and a seventh shattering the wall right by his head. He remained motionless for what felt like an eternity until the laughter and chimes of “he’s dead” faded out.

Civil War Survivors Syrian Civil WarAbove: Rebels in the fight against ISIS and the Syrian regime. Photo courtesy Rojava Information Center.

Samer managed to drag himself down a flight of crooked stairs and phone a friend for help. However, his miraculous tale of survival would only become dizzying as the war intensified into chemical attacks and mortar showers — until one day in 2015. He was given passage to flee into neighboring Turkey, an opportunity he felt would be his last chance at life. From there, he boarded a rickety boat to Greece and then moved through to Germany. Today, he’s trying to move on with life and studies, yet not leave behind the Syrian war that protracts into its eleventh year.

“I don’t know why I survived. I would say it is God’s will. I ask myself why me, and still, I have no answer,” Samer said.

Physically, he’s no longer able to lift his right arm. Psychologically, Samer is awash with an unrelenting desire to keep fighting for his country — this time with his voice.

“I’m going to run for parliament in Germany,” he noted, his strained face thawing into a wistful smile. “That’s the best I can do to protect my future family.”

China

Jennifer Zeng’s crumble into suffocating oppression under the fist of China’s Communist Party (CCP) was beleaguered from the beginning. She entered the world in the Sichuan province in 1966, the year that the Mao Zedong’s Cultural Revolution — the great sociopolitical purge to cement communism — began.

Since her father was part of a secret “intellectual” crowd, he was always on the oust of Beijing’s militant leadership and subsequently ostracized. This meant that Jennifer was born in a clinic where her parents couldn’t afford to pay bribes for the best medical care. As a result, a blood transfusion gone wrong in her first few days of life left her with hepatitis C.

Ironically, it was that liver-ravishing condition that would, decades later, save her life. Her early life was plagued with mandatory “re-education” classes on the fringes of an isolated town, forcibly separated from her mother. Any minor change her father wanted to make, from work to moving to a different house, couldn’t be done without government approval.

Hong Kong Democracy Protest

“My childhood was very lonely. And because my family was looked down on by society, I was discriminated against — even the school would not let me play with other kids,” she said wistfully, her eyes darting off into another world. “We had to be very careful, and life was very hard.”

She didn’t know then just how much harder it would become.

It wasn’t until 1997, when Jennifer was in her early 30s and working in Beijing, that she stumbled upon furtively distributed books about an emerging spiritual adherence called Falun Gong. It was a belief system outside the purview of the authoritarian leadership. For two years, she’d meet other practitioners to pray and meditate under the shroud of secrecy. 

Then, in the summer of 1999 — after hearing that other Falun Gong believers were being apprehended — Jennifer went to the State Appeals Office to plead their case. But authorities abruptly rounded her up too. She was stuffed into a detention center for 48 hours, and her name etched into a black book that would haunt her for many more years. 

Inside the labor camps, time was double-edged. The seconds of torture were elastic — stretching on, with one always waiting for the tenuous band to snap. But the longer she could keep propelling through, the closer she felt to making it to the other side.

Jennifer was arrested for the second time in February 2000. This time, she was dragged out from her workplace — an investment consultant company — and viciously interrogated at a labor camp in China’s Da Xing County. Before officials drew her blood, she informed them that she had hepatitis C. While she was left to starve over the coming weeks, many around her — including her cellmate — dropped dead from forced feeding. 

That’s when Jennifer realized that the organs of Falun Gong practitioners were being nightmarishly harvested to meet the demands of a government-run for-profit organ industry. She was eventually released from this torturous captivity, but not for long. That April, heavy-handed police officers plucked Jennifer from her sleep just after the witching hour with no explanation. 

It was only days later that she learned authorities had intercepted an email she had written to her parents, explaining her zest for the Falun Gong faith despite it being outlawed by the CCP. While some criticize it as being something of a cult, Jennifer maintains that her Falun Gong practice is rooted in meditation and compassion.

But for weeks that swelled into months, Jennifer’s life in yet another labor camp would fall to the hands of that faith. 

“Every day was a struggle between life and death. Most days, we were forced to squat for 16 hours, with our hands behind our heads like dogs. Police would immediately apply electric batons to anyone who fainted to wake them up,” she said. “On the other days, we were made to stand motionless in our cell for those 16 hours.”

When Jennifer refused to renounce her religion as “evil,” prison guards lugged her into a filthy courtyard and whipped her raw with electric rods until she lost consciousness. Yet, the worst pain wasn’t physical. It was watching once bright-eyed humans descend behind the curtain of madness. 

“At night, you would hear the screams of those being tortured. Sometimes, I felt that I would collapse and lose my sanity. That was the most terrible fear for me,” Jennifer continued. “You could see the moment when someone would lose their sanity — when they couldn’t handle the mental torture anymore. Their eyes changed. Their minds went somewhere else.”

As soon as she was set free months later, Jennifer knew that China was no longer home. The only way she would survive was to be somewhere safe enough to tell the world what was happening to the Falun Gong practitioners. She had to make the excruciating decision to leave her 10-year-old daughter and husband behind and flee first to Australia as an asylum seeker in 2001. Years later, Jennifer relocated to the United States, where she has continued her advocacy as an independent writer. 

For now, watching China continue to assault minorities from the Muslim Uighurs to the Buddhist Tibetans from afar is like observing a slow-burning home from behind a frosted glass window. The nightmares haven’t stopped, but Jennifer leans on meditation and deep breathing until the fear fades away. It’s those pillars of benevolence toward all forms of life that pull her through the darkest of days.

“That is the greatest gift, the best skill that I can give myself,” she says with a smile.

Burma

For M Tu Aung, 46, life has always existed as an endless cycle of running — running from danger, running into the unknown, running to lands far away and then running in circles in the hopes someone might hear his cries and prayers.

M Tu Aung Civil War survivorAbove: M Tu Aung outside the Chinese Embassy in DC in April 2021, protesting the military takeover in Burma. Above: Photo by Hollie McKay

“We had to run whenever the military would come in. They would try to kill all the people, they would set fire to the villages and burn down the churches,” recalled Aung. He was raised in the predominantly Christian Kachin State of Burma — also known by its 1989 regime re-title Myanmar — during a time of socialist military governance. “If you could not run, if you were not fast enough, you would be taken by the Burmese Army. Many times, people were killed, and yet we could not stop to bury the bodies — if they caught you, they would kill you. Some of my family members who were running beside me were caught.”

Burma has been burned alive by endless conflicts and persecution since the British handed the country back its independence in 1948. Given the endless wars, Aung never knew his biological parents and was adopted as an infant. He also never knew a life not beset by killing fields.

“They (Armed Forces) wanted all the property for themselves. We always had to run and leave our village and property behind. Everything would be ruined; the Army has no regard for human life,” he continued. “Every day, we lived in fear. We worried, day and night, they would come.”

Civil War SurvivorsAbove: Photo by Hollie McKay

Even if there were peaceful moments inside the threads of the jungle, idyllic in their stillness, they were beset by biting anxiety. There were no warning signs, Aung said, just a crackle of gunfire and howls of panic whenever the troops would force their way in. 

“What I remember most about my childhood is how the soldiers would just come into our villages and take anything they wanted. And they would take the people — sometimes 15 or 16 years old,” he whispered.

Like many from the region, the more painful the topic, the more the survivor laughs — an uncomfortable defense mechanism to mask the invisible wounds nested into memory.

“The Burmese Army would kill and torture — and they would rape,” he said slowly. “I remembered the faces of the young girls and women who they would take away to rape. We didn’t know exactly where they were taking them, but the ladies — most of them — never came back.”

Aung believes he only survived a tumultuous upbringing because his adoptive parents moved him to Rakhine State when he was 15, a state that — back then — was somewhat less butchered.

A decade ago, Aung was granted asylum in the United States with the wild hope for a better life. He studied for an MBA and opened a small business in Maryland. He fell in love with another refugee from Burma, married and had three children, and is heavily involved in the local community of Baptists churches. 

Civil War SurvivorsAbove: Photo by Hollie McKay

But it’s the place he left behind that occupies his mind during most waking hours. He exhibits a dogged devotion in reaching out to the powers of Washington as an active leader in the Nationalities Alliance of Burma, a network of ethnic nationalities organizations based in the United States.

“It has always been about a ‘burmainization’ of the country, of everyone else not in the military circle being treated as second class,” Aung lamented. “The Burmese military wants us out to protect themselves. It is why they are killing protestors and civilians every day.”

Some of Aung’s frustrations have stemmed from the notion that little has been conveyed to the public about the suffering of Christians in Burma. Most of the world is painfully aware of the persecution that the Muslim Rohingyas have endured in recent years in the Rakhine State he settled in as a teen, with many forced to flee into bordering Bangladesh. Aung said Christians have also been slaughtered and have had their houses of worship razed into nothingness, but have been “weak” at conveying the situation on social media.

Civil War Survivors ChurchAbove: Photo by Hollie McKay

“The ethnic cleansing has been happening since long before that of the Rohingya people,” Aung stressed.

Watching his homeland once again be dipped in chaos and blood following the coup in February 2021, in which the military wrestled power back from the first civilian government, Aung feels the urge to keep running. He’s calling for the international community to step in and support a transitional government in that illustrious chase for a free and fair election, calling for the people of Burma to decide their fate.

And despite 10 years in the United States, Aung clings to a life of trauma that reminds him he may never truly know what it is to be safe and secure. He leads a minimalist life with no stockpiling — when all one knows is to run, less is more — and his body is engulfed by chills at the mere sight of any uniformed soldier.

“Even here in the U.S., I just don’t want to see a soldier. It scares me,” he notes with a nervous giggle. “All that is really left, all we can do, is pray for protection. That helps us a lot.”

Egypt

Then, there’s the case of Mohammed Soltan, 33, in which the torture of the unknown still visits him at night. His father “disappeared” months ago into the depths of an Egyptian prison. Last year, intelligence officials informed him that prison guards broke his dad’s jaw and his teeth, yelling that it was his son’s “treachery” for which he must pay the price.

Yet Mohammed, a former Egyptian political prisoner himself, refuses to be silenced. He also refuses to wear the weight of guilt that his dad is suffering because of his vocal activism against the military leadership in Cairo.

“I won’t take that on,” Mohammed said defiantly. “That is on them.”

Civil War Survivors Mohamed Soltan The New York TimesAbove: Mohamed Soltan poses for a photo at his sister’s home in Fairfax, Va., on Friday, August 21, 2015. Soltan spent over two years in jail in Egypt including a year on hunger strike. (Photo by Zach Gibson / The New York Times)

His father and five cousins are being housed in the recesses of the very same underground prison Mohammed was thrown into in August 2013.

But his journey of political activism was one of default. He grew up in what he describes as simple, rural American life in the Midwest — white picket fences, sprinkler summers, and frosty winters. But when the 2011 Arab Spring erupted in Egypt, the place of his heritage, Mohammed wanted to experience what he hoped would be real change in the region.

“I remember watching the protests in my history class at Ohio State University and just knowing that I needed to be there,” Mohammed recollects. “I left the airport and went straight to Tahir Square. It was February 11, and longtime President Hosni Mubarak stepped down. It felt like the whole trajectory of my life had changed. It seemed like a dream. The young people of Egypt had spoken, and we had taken our country back.”

Only his dream of freedom fast descended into a nightmare. After completing his studies in the U.S., Mohammed moved with his father to Egypt in March 2013 to build a life working with the newly elected Mohamed Morsi leadership. However, just a few months later, Egyptians poured into the streets to showcase their displeasure at Morsi, setting up a succession of clashes.

After a few days of demonstrations, the country’s former defense minister Gen. Abdel Fattah el-Sisi oversaw a controversial takeover of power. That part of it had been relatively sudden, Mohammed said. There had been no warning signs to get out early. It seemed that the transition would be one decided by the people … until it was not.

“I was very scared that the military was coming back and interrupting a democratic space. We had hoped there might be a referendum,” Mohammed continued.

The summer flared with the heat of protests and confusion swarming the streets, both in support and in objection to the Army’s government overhaul. Mohammed had been live-tweeting about the chaos erupting around him at Rabaa Square when a bullet zipped past his head. But before he could breathe relief at the near miss, another bullet tore through his arm.

While attempting to tend to his wound without access to proper medical care, Egyptian authorities burst through his home. They were initially looking for his dad, who wasn’t there. So instead, Mohammed was taken away in what would amount to months of beatings, cigarette burns melting his unwashed flesh, the cracks of his bones breaking and the gut-wrenching feeling of his left shoulder dislocating from his deltoid muscle. 

He remembers nails being pressed into his wasting frame during regular torture sessions, and the way his angst would spew into anger every time authorities attempted to force-feed him. Each time, he’d immediately tear the IV drip out of his weakening body.

While behind bars, Mohammed launched a hunger strike that stretched from months into more than a year.

As an American, Mohammed had a robust government on his side that was able to demand his release. After 22 months — including 489 days on a hunger strike, wrapped in despair — he was set free into the sunshine on May 31, 2015. But as any torture survivor will tell you, there’s never really a place one can call home. After that, authorities retaliated by arresting five of his cousins and his father.

Along with the deep pangs of knowing that his dad is still out there in the darkness of the dungeons, alone and in misery, Mohammed still frantically jumps at the sound of keys shaking or doors slamming — sounds that signified the guards coming into his cell for another round of caustic games. His stomach violently rejects heavy meals, and being alone comes with a bundle of distressing solitary confinement reminders.

“I have to keep speaking to myself,” he said. “It’s how I can assure myself that I am still alive.”

The work is far from over. Mohammed’s life now is stuffed with pushing for the release of other political prisoners around the planet, in what he characterizes as “paying it forward.”

“I didn’t think that I ever would get out of prison, and I know that any of us can die at any minute,” he conjectured. “But I have this second lease on my life to fight for others, and that’s the lens through which I view everything. That is why I will be forever grateful.”

Uganda

The upheaval of one’s life isn’t always at the behest of one’s own government. Sometimes, the lack of stability and internal corruption of leadership lays the groundwork for external influences to swoop in and unleash havoc on an innocent populace.

That’s an eerie narrative that Victoria Nyanjura knows all too well. She was just 14 years old when insurgents, under the canopy of Joseph Kony’s Lord’s Resistance Army (LRA), stole her and some 138 other girls from their Catholic boarding school in the Kole district of northern Uganda. These events unfolded in the dead of the night on October 9, 1996.

There had been rumblings weeks earlier that the rebel outfit might invade, yet nothing had come of it. When it happened, it came as a scalding shock — grenades detonated in the dark, wild-eyed fighters rattled the gates until they broke, and then there were the screams. The piercing screams that Victoria will never forget as she glanced up into an abnormally bright sky.

“I tried to hide under the bed, but they found me and took me. I didn’t know what was happening,” she observed, in a small yet stern voice that signified her propensity to push through. “I did not know whether they would let me live or die. But that was the start of all my misery.”

Kony’s name and his trail of terror didn’t become apparent to most Americans until 2012, when the abuses of his self-styled militias were brought to light in a viral video focused on recruiting child soldiers. But for eight years, many moons earlier, it was all Victoria lived and breathed. Thirty of the 139 girls were handpicked and dragged away to be bush wives to the insurgents. Nyanjura was plucked and tied up with banana leaves so she couldn’t run, and immediately she knew with a sinking feeling her life would never be the same.

“Every night, they are having their way with you, and there is nothing you can do. Everything about captivity is about survival. You either survive, or you perish; there is no in-between,” Victoria said. “Often, you would see someone fall to the ground and think they must be resting, but when you get closer, you realize they are gone.”

Victoria Nyanjura Civil War survivorAbove: Victoria Nyanjura

Her years of survival were pockmarked by sucking raindrops and dew for water, secretly gathering wild fruits and hoping that they would not be poisonous, sitting in the sunshine with a body so bruised and swollen, and sobbing to live. Other times, she was sobbing to die.

Victoria’s “husband” was eventually killed in the fighting against Ugandan forces, and for years more, she held her two small children — a daughter and a son — tight and quietly prayed and wept for the will to keep forging ahead. The LRA distinguished itself by slicing off victims’ limbs, lips, and noses — a symbol to instill terror in communities and scar survivors for life, making them forever dependent on others to get by.

“There were times that I begged to God to let me die, that things would be better if I were not there,” Victoria confessed. “I begged if I died; I wanted my children to die too. I wanted us all to perish together.”

One day, Victoria snapped. By that point, she was 22 years old, and much of her life had existed in the confines of captivity, on the tightrope of death and destruction, in the shadow of the grossest miscarriage of justice. She could not take it for one moment longer. With that, Victoria swept up her two children and set off a daring escape that entailed weeks of weaving through a boundless maze of jungle and gray sheets of tropical rain, over hills and into valleys of the dead — praying that she wouldn’t be shot at or re-captured, or step on a land mine embedded in the muddy tracks.

Eventually, Victoria made it to a displacement camp, where she was forced to confront the stigma of surviving sexual violence and shielding her young from the origins of their conception. Now 39, Victoria recently completed a master’s degree in global affairs, focusing on international peace studies, at the University of Notre Dame.

Yet last year, she chose to return to Uganda not only to start explaining to her now-grown children what had happened, but to support other women and survivors of traumas with her own non-governmental organization. Victoria admitted that she struggles to have any sense of a typical romantic relationship and accepts that the healing process is jagged with steps forward and steps back.

But her voice is resilient, with a fierce protectiveness of her children. She will never let happen to them what happened to her.

“In captivity, I called my daughter Hope. There was no other name I could give her because I just had to have hope that God would get us home,” Victoria added. “For anyone in a tough situation, I would say never give up on life. Never give in, never give up. You have to have hope for a better tomorrow.” 


Only Cry for the Living

Only Cry for the Living book cover

Memos from Inside the ISIS Battlefield

Get your copy of Hollie McKay’s latest book by going to gundigeststore.com/living.


MORE LESSONS FROM CONFLICT


Gun Maintenance Multi Tool: Pocket Preps

Most firearm malfunctions are caused by a lack of proper maintenance. Like any other machine, firearms experience wear and tear after prolonged use. Dirt, rust, carbon buildup, and worn-out or broken parts can cause stoppages or even catastrophic failure. Regular cleaning, lubrication, and inspection of a firearm is necessary to keep it operating smoothly and ensuring early detection of damaged components. 

Modern firearm platforms like the AR-15 require specialized tools for sighting, cleaning, and adjusting. Even the 100-year-old 1911 platform requires a special bushing wrench for disassembly. The most basic field armorer kit typically consists of enough punches, wrenches, drivers, bits, and other tools to fill a medium-sized tool bag. 

The expense of a full maintenance kit is more than most gun owners will ever wish to invest. Those who have sacrificed their hard-earned cash to acquire these tools will frequently find themselves stuck at the range in want of a tool they left at home, because their tool kits were too heavy and cumbersome to haul with them. 

One of the best ways to increase productivity at the range is to have all the tools needed to make sight adjustments, tighten loose accessories, and disassemble and clean your gun. A quality gun maintenance multi-tool can provide most of those tools in a compact package that can be conveniently stowed in a range bag. 

In this edition of Pocket Preps, we’ll examine some of the most versatile gun maintenance multi-tools on the market. As we look at the capabilities and limitations of each tool, we hope to provide the reader with the information needed to select the best multi-tool for the job.


Multitasker Twist

Dimensions: 5 by 9/16 inches
Weight: 1.8 ounces (3.7 ounces with included bits)
MSRP: $60
URL: multitaskertools.com

Multitasker Twist Multi tool

The Twist is nothing short of a pocket toolbox packed into the size and shape of a large permanent marker. The rear section of the double-ended, threaded housing holds a pick for scraping stubborn carbon deposits and pulling retainer pins, a 3/32-inch pin punch, and a radial carbon scraper. These three tools attach to the 8-32 thread adapter located on the front cap. Underneath the front cap is a magnetic ¼-inch bit driver with an AR front sight tool installed. The Twist comes with a few Phillips, slotted, hex, and Torx bits, but any ¼ bit can be used with the driver. The rear cap has a two-prong Aimpoint micro sight turret adjuster on the end, making this tool invaluable to any Aimpoint shooter. When the rear cap is removed, the pocket clip becomes a field expedient, lightweight flathead driver.

Multitasker Twist Multi tool

Pros:

  • Marker-style housing is easy to carry.
  • Saves space and weight while offering essential tools
  • Can be used in conjunction with pull-through cleaning kits

Cons:

  • Small number of tools within the unit
  • Aluminum housing doesn’t allow the use of a hammer when using the pin punch

Real Avid AR15 Tool

Dimensions: 5 by 2 by 1 Inches
Weight: 118.4 Ounces
MSRP: $90
URL: realavid.com

Real Avid AR15 Tool Multi tool

This 37-in-1 tactical gun multi-tool on a folding X-frame platform has everything necessary to remove carbon from bolt surfaces, make field repairs, add or remove accessories, and completely disassemble and reassemble a firearm. The AR15 Tool contains needle-nose pliers, carbide cutter, metal file, bolt carrier carbon scraper, 8-32 threaded receiver and post to attach all standard cleaning attachments, 3/32-inch detachable pin punch, 10-function bolt carrier group scraper, cotter pin puller, serrated tanto blade, detachable hook pick, three-position locking ¼-inch bit driver with 12 bits, and a bolt override tool. The MOLLE-compatible nylon sheath has elastic bit storage loops and an A1 and A2 front sight tool storage pouch on the side. Although it’s designed as an AR tool, this beefy device works for pistols too.

Real Avid AR15 Tool Multi tool

Pros:

  • Full-featured multi-tool has everything needed for field maintenance.
  • Convenient nylon case
  • G-10 side-plates increase gripping surface.
  • Very cost-effective

Cons:

  • Heavy
  • The overall size is a bit bulky and makes precise task work cumbersome.

Real Avid Gun Tool AMP – AR15

Dimensions: 5 1/2 by 2 by 1 5/8 inches
Weight: 13.3 Ounces
MSRP: $70
URL: realavid.com

Real Avid Gun Tool AMP - AR15

The Gun Tool AMP is a series of compact multi-tools that come in three platform-specific versions, AR15, Pistol, and 1911. The AR15 version shown here contains a tanto-style knife blade, bolt override tool, takedown punch, retaining pin puller, multi-surface bolt carrier group scraper, carrier scraper, firing pin scraper, and tap hammer. All tools lock in place using a liner lock system. The holster has a fold-out, locking ¼-inch bit driver and a nine-function bit set. Bits include hex, Torx, Phillips, flat, and A2 Front Sight Adjuster. The folding driver arm locks into place with a quick release lever. The holster has a MOLLE-compatible, metal belt clip for convenient stowing and transport. The AMP is a specialized tool, so the user needs to choose the right platform.

Real Avid Gun Tool AMP - AR15

Pros:

  • Case with driver and primary tool separate, allowing the user to work with each independently
  • Each AMP platform has everything needed to perform field maintenance and cleaning.
  • Functional sheath reduces waisted space.

Cons:

  • Specialized platform is weapon specific.
  • Weight

Multitasker Nano

Dimensions: 1.2 by 0.5 inches
Weight: 0.1 Ounces
MSRP: $13
URL: multitaskertools.com

Multitasker NANO multi tool

The Multitasker Nano Tool is a tiny pocket tool intended for making optic adjustments. It’s about the size of an aluminum can flip tab but packs a lot of practical utility despite its tiny footprint. The Nano features a dedicated Aimpoint T1/T2 turret adjuster on one end and a slotted screwdriver with radiused edges on the other. Although the Nano can be conveniently carried on a keychain using the built-in lanyard hole, the Nano has been specifically engineered with winglets on each side, which act as a dovetail for docking into the SpaceFrame storage slot found on the Gen3 MagPod. The Nano is compatible with a wide variety of popular optics and aiming lasers, including the Aimpoint M68 CCO, EOTech EXPS-3, Trijicon ACOG, Trijicon RMR, PEQ-15, and the B.E. Meyers & Co. MAWL.

Multitasker NANO

Pros:

  • Tiny and easy to carry
  • Compatible with the Gen-3 MagPod SpaceFrame storage slot
  • Works with the most popular optics and lasers

Cons:

  •  Functionality is mostly limited to aiming devices.
  •  Easy to misplace or lose due to its size

Gerber Short Stack

Dimensions: 3 by 1.25 by 5/8 inches
Weight: 2.8 Ounces
MSRP: $47
URL: gerbergear.com

Gerber Short Stack Multi tool

The Gerber Short Stack uses a revolutionary three-piece magnetic design to form a compact, weapon-specific multi-tool. The Short Stack has everything needed to disassemble and maintain the AR rifle platform, including a front sight tool, firing pin scraper, bolt and bolt carrier scraper, cleaning cable pull-through handle, castle nut wrench, 4mm wrench/bit driver, 7mm wrench (fits M-LOK fasteners), ½-inch wrench, 3/8-inch wrench, ¾-inch wrench, curved slotted driver, and two double-sided Hex bits (#0 Cross Diver, T10, 1/8-inch Hex, 4mm Hex). This tiny, self-contained multi-tool can fit snugly into Magpul MOE and MIAD pistol grips so it’s always close by when the rifle is in hand. 

Gerber Short Stack Multi tool

Pros:

  • Extremely light and compact
  • Can be stored inside the weapon
  • Cost effective

Cons:

  • Small size reduces leverage.
  • AR-platform specific
  • Doubles as a brain puzzle when returning the tool to its carry configuration

Emissary Development R2-0

Dimensions: 3.5 by 1 1/8 by 5/16 inches
Weight: 0.5
MSRP: TBD
URL: emissarydevelopment.com

Emissary Development R2-0 Multi Tool

The R2-0 (Return 2 Zero) is a lightweight minimalist tool designed through a collaborative effort between Emissary Development and Unity Tactical. The R2-0 is designed to interface with Geissele Super Precision Scope Mounts and snaps in place between the mounting screws using a clamp/hook design. The tool houses a T15 Torx bit that fits into a ¼-inch socket on the undercarriage. An additional ½-inch socket fits standard scope mount nuts and can be used to tighten loosening mounts or make mounting adjustments. The lack of any torque limiter means the R2-0 isn’t ideal for use with precision weapons; however, it’s a handy tool for tightening a loose scope mount on the range or in the field. 

Emissary Development R2-0 Multi Tool

Pros:

  • Conveniently locks into the Geissele Scope Mount for convenient storage

Cons:

  • User must have the Geissele Scope Mount for the tool to interface.
  • The lack of torque limiter makes it impractical for precision use.

Fix It Sticks The Works

Dimensions: 7.25 by 3 by 4.25 inches
Weight: 26.2 Ounces
MSRP: $280
URL: fixitsticks.com

Fix It Sticks The Works Multi Tool

This all-in-one gun maintenance kit contains a variety of tools that come in handy at the range or work bench, including an A2 front sight tool, castle nut wrench, bolt carrier scraper, 1911 bushing tool, Glock front sight bit, universal choke tube wrench, metal pin punch and a non-marring plastic pin punch, bronze scraper, steel pick, set of brass 8-32 thread cleaning rods, set of two 8-32 bit adapters, cleaning brush, and mini pry bar. There are four torque limiters (15, 25, 45, and 65 inch-pounds), a ½-inch socket, and 24 assorted ¼-inch bits for mounting scopes, tightening chassis, and zeroing optics. Every tool pairs with the accompanying ¼-inch T-handle wrench. The entire kit packs inside a compact, MOLLE-webbed soft case. A magnetic Velcro patch on the outside of the case helps keep track of loose screws and bits. The Works has it all.

Fix It Sticks The Works Multi Tool

Pros:

  • Has virtually everything a shooter needs for field maintenance
  • Multi-platform tools for a variety of firearms
  • Standard ¼-inch bits and driver make this multi-tool highly customizable and adaptable.

Cons:

  • Price 

More Pocket Preps

MORE POCKET PREPS


Stop The Bleeding: A Guide to Hemostatic Agent Choices

One of the most important skills for the family medic to master is the ability to rapidly stop bleeding (also known as “achieving hemostasis”). In survival scenarios, bleeding can occur from various sources, from a fall on uneven terrain to a hostile encounter with another group. Failure to properly treat bleeding wounds can lead to unnecessary deaths among survivors. A 2013 study reported in Military Times found that close to 25 percent of the combat deaths in Iraq and Afghanistan between 2001 and 2011 might have been survivable with rapid and appropriate actions. One result is the second look at hemostatic agent options available. 

Certainly, the survival medic can save some lives with the right knowledge, training, and equipment. For example, a caregiver with a tourniquet will be more successful than one without. In addition to tourniquets, there are commercially available hemorrhage control (also known as “hemostatic”) agents that are effective in stopping even heavy bleeding.

The ideal hemostatic agent is one that works quickly, is easily portable, has few complications, and doesn’t interfere with tissue healing. Oh, one more thing: It must be available at a reasonable price. Unfortunately, the most effective dressings like QuikClot, Celox, and ChitoSam aren’t cheap; it may be difficult, financially, for the average citizen to stockpile enough to deal with multiple bleeding wounds.

hemostatic agentsAbove: Even the best-equipped medic can run out of supplies off the grid.

It’s clear that a caregiver in austere settings must improvise once the commercial hemostatic agent options are gone. What options are out there that could help stop the bleed besides just applying direct pressure and hoping for the best? Direct pressure with both hands and your full weight on the wound may be successful, but what if it isn’t? Elevation of a bleeding extremity might help, but what if it doesn’t?

The answer might be growing in your own backyard. Certain plants are known for their blood-clotting abilities; it’s important to either grow them in a medicinal garden or know where they exist in the great outdoors. Some of the items below may not yet have hard scientific proof of effectiveness. Despite this, they might be all you have when the commercial materials run out.


How Blood Clots

Hemostasis is the control of bleeding. As soon as a blood vessel wall is damaged, the body reacts to close the breach: 

Primary Hemostasis: Tiny particles in the blood known as platelets start clumping together at the breach in the vessel, attracting even more platelets and forming a “plug.”

Secondary Hemostasis: Clotting factors in the blood form strands of a material called fibrin, which deposits around the injury and forms a mesh with the platelet plug that seals the wound. 

The whole thing dries and hardens, forming a clot. Over time, the clot dissolves.


Yarrow

Yarrow (Achillea millefolium), was known in ancient times as “herba militaris” for its use in staunching the flow of blood from wounds. Indeed, the Greek hero Achilles is said to have carried it during the Trojan War. It’s native to temperate regions almost everywhere in the Northern Hemisphere, from sea level to altitudes of 11,500 feet.

hemostatic agents yarrow on gauzeAbove: Yarrow on gauze.

To stop bleeding, yarrow is normally used as a powder made from grinding dried leaves and flowers, but applying fresh plant material in a poultice is also acceptable. Cover the natural hemostatic agent with gauze and apply pressure. Elevate if the wound is in an extremity.

Cayenne Pepper

Cayenne pepper (Capsicum annuum) isn’t just meant to spice up your meal — the capsaicin in it is thought to have a coagulating effect on mild bleeding as well as some antibacterial properties. To be effective, you have to use a lot of the most potent cayenne you can find in powder form. Pour it directly on the wound, cover with gauze or other cloth, and apply pressure for several minutes. Multiple applications may be needed. 

Won’t cayenne pepper powder burn when applied? Having applied it on myself and seen it applied to bleeding injuries in dogs without a pain response, the answer is not much. 

Tea

For dental bleeding after an extraction, black or green tea (Camellia sinensis) may be used. Teas contain tannins, which are thought to help blood to clot by making vessels constrict. They may also have antiseptic properties. Teas with caffeine are thought to be more effective. 

hemostatic agents teaAbove: Dental bleeding after extraction may be controlled with tea bags and pressure.

Take a tea bag that’s been steeped and allowed to cool, wrap in thin gauze, and place on the bleeding area with pressure. For bleeding after a tooth extraction, have the patient bite down on the tea bag gently but firmly in the now-empty socket. If bleeding is from the inside of the cheek or other area in the oral cavity, place against the bleeding area and apply pressure on the area from outside with the mouth closed. 

Some believe that tea compresses may help with mild external cuts on the skin. Press a dry green or black tea bag against the wound, cover with gauze or other cloth, and apply pressure.

Witch Hazel

Witch hazel is a temperate North American shrub. “Witch” doesn’t refer to practitioners of magic, but the Middle English word for “bendable.” Distilled witch hazel has an astringent effect that tightens skin, constricts small blood vessels, and promotes clotting. Apply a small amount of the hemostatic agent to a compress and press on the wound. Pure witch hazel can be found at most drugstores.

hemostatic agents witch hazelAbove: Witch hazel and gauze squares.

Other common plants that have an astringent effect include plantain, rose, and horsetail. Be aware that people may sometimes be allergic to certain plants, so monitor closely for rashes, itching, or other signs of a reaction.

Non-Plant Hemostatic Agent Options

While a number of plants are reputed to stop bleeding, you might be surprised to know that the two main products used in expensive commercial blood-clotters are actually: 1) a type of clay, and 2) the shells of shrimp and other crustaceans.

Kaolin Clay

Kaolin clay is the main ingredient in the popular commercial hemostatic agent QuikClot. It was once the main ingredient in the anti-diarrheal drug Kaopectate (it’s now Bismuth Subsalicylate, the same ingredient used in Pepto-Bismol). Kaolin is scientifically proven to stop bleeding. Contact between kaolin and blood immediately initiates the clotting process by activating Factor XII, a major player in the cascade of events that stops hemorrhage. 

Hemostatic Agents Kaolin ClayAbove: Dip gauze in water and coat with kaolin powder.

Kaolin is commercially available for purchase in powder form. Apply the clay powder directly to a bleeding wound or onto a dressing and then on the injury. Kaolin dressings can be improvised by dipping cotton gauze or cloth in water and allowing to dry. Like the commercial version, firm direct pressure on the area for several minutes is required for full effect.

Hemostatic Agent Kaolin Clay how to Above: Mix kaolin into a paste.

It should be noted that kaolin doesn’t cause burns when used. This is the reason that QuikClot switched to it years ago after bad experiences with the former main ingredient known as zeolite.

Hemostatic Agent Kaolin Clay how to Above: Spread out wet dressings onto a drying rack.

Hemostatic Agent Kaolin Clay how to Above: Place wet kaolin gauze into a dehydrator at 105 degrees.

Hemostatic Agent Kaolin Clay how to Above: These photos show a few fabrics used to improvise kaolin dressings.

Chitosan

Chitosan is a naturally occurring part of the exoskeletons of crustaceans like shrimp. Processed in a way that prevents reactions in those allergic to shellfish, it’s highly effective as a blood-clotting agent and can be found in products like ChitoSam, Celox, and others. When chitosan products come into contact with blood, they bond with it and form a gel plug that acts as a clot. Unlike kaolin, chitosan doesn’t use up the body’s clotting factors, something beneficial to those who may have a deficiency of these important substances.

Chitosan can be purchased as a powder. Use vinegar to moisten gauze pads and dip both sides into a bowl of the powder just like you would bread a piece of chicken. Use a dehydrator or oven on low heat to make your own hemostatic agent infused dressings. Alternatively, freeze and then use dry ice in a covered container with holes to achieve a similar effect.

Kaolin clay, animal, or botanical products may be the answer to bleeding control in some cases, but certain other common items have the potential to staunch blood loss.

Ice

Like some astringent plants, applying ice to a wound will constrict small blood vessels. In minor bleeds, ice might allow a clot to form more quickly while reducing swelling. Wrap some ice in a clean, dry cloth and place on the wound with gentle pressure to avoid traumatizing skin.

hemostatic agents iceAbove: Ice packs help constrict smaller blood vessels.

Antiperspirants

Some antiperspirants contain aluminum chloride, another astringent that might constrict small blood vessels. Aluminum chloride as low as 5 percent concentration exerted a hemostatic effect through a chemical reaction and was deemed effective in a 2015 study. Aluminum sulfate, the ingredient in styptic pencils to treat bleeding from cuts incurred while shaving, is a related product.

Petroleum Jelly

For shallow cuts, petroleum jelly may be an option to slow bleeding. You may have been a spectator at a boxing match where the manager treats his fighter’s injuries with it. Apply a layer on a minor bleed with direct pressure. Once the bleeding has stopped, blot the jelly off and clean the wound.

hemostatic agents petroleum jellyAbove: Petroleum jelly dressing on simulated wound.

Tactical Tampons?

Another bleeding-control improvisation you’ll often hear about is the “tactical tampon.” There’s a persistent notion that this feminine sanitary product is an excellent addition to your medical kit. There are many, usually second-hand, accounts that these items saved the life of a soldier because a savvy medic made sure to have some on hand. 

Why wouldn’t a tampon work as a hemostatic agent? After all, it might be the right size to plug a bullet hole. When a projectile strikes soft tissue at high speed, however, it creates a channel through which the projectile travels. As a matter of fact, it causes two channels — a permanent one caused by the actual path and a larger, temporary one caused by the energy wave released into the body by the round’s impact. Vessels and organs affected by this secondary shock wave might not be in the direct line of the permanent cavity (and the subsequent tampon placement), but can be damaged and easily bleed.

hemostatic agents tamponAbove: The tampon would just conceal the bleeding, not stop it … Just because you don’t see a hemorrhage doesn’t mean it isn’t happening. A saturated tampon can only hold about 20cc of blood.

Bullets traveling at high speeds go deeper into the body than a tampon can reach. Plugging a hole, even one that looks like it could fit a tampon, doesn’t stop the hemorrhage inside. It just pools internally or finds an exit wound. The tampon would just conceal the bleeding, not stop it. Even the most absorbent tampon can only handle about 15 grams or so of blood. The rest has to go somewhere. Just because you don’t see a hemorrhage doesn’t mean it isn’t happening. “Successes” in the field were, probably, nightmares for the surgical team after evacuation.


Mistakes When Stopping the Bleed

Rapid action by those at the scene can save lives, but some common mistakes can lead to tragic outcomes:

  •  Panic! The shock of seeing a major hemorrhage can cause hesitation to act.
  •  Being timid when applying pressure to the wound (yes, it’s going to hurt).
  •  Failing to pack dressings directly onto the bleeding vessel.
  •  Failing to apply pressure to a commercial hemostatic dressing for three full minutes or longer for improvised dressings.       
  •  Hesitating to apply a tourniquet as a first course of action in cases of heavy bleeding.
  •  Failing to apply a compression bandage over the hemostatic dressing.
  •  Assuming a controlled hemorrhage doesn’t require close monitoring for re-bleeds.

Closing Thoughts // Hemostatic Agent

Are the above strategies as good as having high-tech commercially made hemostatic agent or dressings? Unfortunately, no. None of these improvisations would have the standardized production process and assure sterility as well as a commercially manufactured dressing like QuikClot, Celox, or ChitoSam. Since it’s likely that the infection rates off-the-grid would be higher than in normal times, it’s worth having some in your medical storage. But if the commercial items run out and the options we mention here are all you have, they could still make the difference between life and death. As Teddy Roosevelt once said, “Do what you can, with what you have, where you are.” 


About the Author

Joe Alton, MD, FACOG, FACS, is an actively licensed physician and surgeon, medical preparedness advocate, and New York Times/Amazon bestselling author on medical topics related to austere settings. He’s a member of the Wilderness Medical Society and a certified Advanced Wilderness Expedition Provider. The third edition of his Survival Medicine Handbook won first place in the 2017 Book Excellence Awards in medicine, and his book Alton’s Antibiotics and Infectious Disease won the same award in 2020. His survival medicine website at doomandbloom.net has over 1,200 articles, podcasts, and videos, and has won the Reader’s Choice award on Survivaltop50.com for several consecutive years. The fourth edition of Survival Medicine Handbook is currently available online.


More on Survival and Emergency Medical Skills


Bucky Pratt: A Combat Veteran’s Journey and His Mission to Share Lessons Learned

Few people ever experience actual combat in a war. And of those who do, fewer still turn that experience into something positive. Bucky Pratt is one of these rare individuals who has faced and grappled with his inner demons instead of avoiding them or letting them consume his life. After much introspection, he has turned his passion for traveling and exploration into an example of how others may learn from his hardships.

From a young age, Bucky had a yearning to explore. Growing up in rural Oregon provided ample opportunities to roam the wilderness that he found undeniably enticing. It was a thrill to jump on a bike and pedal over the horizon to a friend’s house or grab his trusty BB gun and wander the edges of farm fields.

Early in his teens, his church provided an opportunity to go on several mission trips. Compelled to see places he had never seen, Bucky was exposed to experiences that changed the trajectory of his life forever. While traveling by bus down the West Coast of the United States to Mexico and witnessing the rich diversity of cultures along the way, Bucky became hooked.

We sat down with Bucky to ask him about what kind of lessons he’s learned about preparation and daily carry after visiting more than 20 countries around the world in less than two years.

RECOIL OFFGRID: What was the catalyst that made you start thinking about traveling the world?

Bucky Pratt: The desire to travel the world has been there since I was a small boy. I was always wondering what was over the next hill or around the bend. It’s what I wanted to do when I got out of the military, but I was not in the right headspace. Going through counseling helped me finally unload some of the burdens of repeated trauma that had been holding me hostage from pursuing what I wanted. For many of us, we have lost so many close friends, people we love. We’ve seen death. We’ve seen the worst of the world. And death is always looming. She’s patiently waiting in the corner. 

Bucky PrattAbove: Enjoying a break on the Koh Nang Yuan viewpoint after kayaking from Koh Tao, Thailand.

During my first deployment, my brothers and I always said, if any of us ever passed, we would live our lives in the best way we could to honor each other. I’m living this life for my brothers and knowing they would be happy to know that I’m pursuing my passion. But it just all kind of came to a point and I was like, it’s time to stop waiting. It’s time to stop putting things off. I just need to f***ing go for it. Take that leap of faith, because what’s the worst that happens? You’ve got to pick yourself up and start over. And even that is great. That was one of the best parts about the military — you’re always challenged in some way.

Why were you drawn to overseas travel instead of just exploring or living a minimalist lifestyle in the United States?

Bucky Pratt: The way I see it, I’m in my 30s, I can backpack around the world now and probably do it for several years. But at some point, I’m going to be that weird old guy who’s backpacking and staying in hostels. At that point, then I can go back to the U.S. and explore there. I’ll be older and you know, maybe my knees won’t be up to the task anymore. Maybe my back won’t be up to it. The chance to live this way abroad may never happen again, and I had to take it.

You must have made many preparations before embarking on your journey. Can you tell us what some of them were?

Bucky Pratt: I did a lot of route planning because originally my goal was to visit 55 countries in a year. I planned numerous routes, looking at maps, flight paths, difficulty of border crossings. Once I had a rough route, I dove into visa requirements — what countries I had to apply ahead of time or didn’t need a visa to enter. I was also trying to follow the seasons and prep for what I thought I would need. I took into consideration a reasonable budget. I’ve spent enough time in adverse conditions, so a slightly more forgiving budget was important. 

Bucky Pratt travelingAbove: Taking a longboat across Inle Lake from Kalaw, Myanmar.

The importance of gear I picked up in the military always carried on with me. There was a lot of time spent picking gear for this trip. I wanted to pack light, which meant everything needed to be dual-purpose. I would go to different outdoor gear stores on the weekends. Trying on every 40- to 65-liter backpack there was, loaded with 30 pounds of weight and walk around to get a feel. If you are going to spend much time wearing gear, you want stuff that’s comfortable. 

How many countries have you visited?

Bucky Pratt Twenty-three during this trip, not even half of what I set out to accomplish. After the first 14 countries there was this turning point when I said, f**k this. I was in Europe and got to the point where if I saw another castle, cathedral, or cobblestone street, I was going to lose it. And maybe that sounds pretentious to say, but Europe wasn’t the excitement I was craving. After being in a combat theatre, going to the Christmas market in Germany doesn’t sound super exciting to me.

Bucky PrattAbove: Heading toward the train tunnel to the Nine Arches Bridge in Ella, Sri Lanka.

What is your traveler’s everyday carry?

Bucky Pratt: Most days I bring my day pack with me. I’m using a Gregory Miwok 18-liter. It has plenty of mileage on it and looks a little beat up. The important items — passport, first-aid kit, cash (local and USD), paracord, multi-tool, headlamp, power bank, pen, notepad, LifeStraw bottle, candy for kids, spirits for adults, tin cup, eating utensil, bottle opener, and a camera. There are other items that come and go depending on my location and what the day holds. 

On my person, wallet, cash (local and USD), cell phone, knife, flashlight, and ear buds. The knife varies depending on location. In places that knives are frowned upon, I carry a small paring knife. If needed for defense, it’ll do the trick, but I can also ditch it at a moment’s notice due to security checkpoints or police. 

Bucky Pratt layout

Above: Staying light on your feet while spending the day exploring a foreign country is an art.  A tried-and-true 18-liter day pack holds the essentials that come in handy while reducing the bulk of larger bags.

How do you keep your first-aid kit easy to bring along?

Bucky Pratt: Typically, just Band-Aids, sterilizing pads, gauze, gloves, pressure dressing, super glue, duct tape, and a tourniquet. Also, some antibacterial or antiseptic cream and eye drops. That’s about it. I keep it fairly basic. I figure if something’s worse than that, it’s a sh*tty day, and I’ll need to seek proper medical services.

Do you find it useful to bring currency?

Bucky Pratt: That generally depends on the country I’m in and how far the money goes. Typically, I like to keep $50 to $90 worth of the local currency. I also keep a $100 in U.S. currency, because if I get in a sticky situation with the cops, $100 is a small price to pay to not end up in a jail. Sometimes slipping someone a $20 bill can get you into places that would otherwise be off-limits. 

It looks like most of your backpacks and clothing are darker colors. Is there any particular reason for this?

Bucky Pratt: Yeah, I don’t like gear that is high-visibility. I like my gear dark and a little beat up. Makes me stand out a little less — anything to draw less attention is important to me. My Caucasian complexion already draws enough attention in some places. The last thing I need is a ridiculously bright bag that peacocks. 

What type of gear do you keep back wherever you are resting your head?

Bucky Pratt: My main pack is a 65-liter Gregory Baltoro. I originally had bought a 55-liter bag and I was like, wow, I don’t have enough space. When I upgraded to the larger size, my goal was to have everything fit in the 65. That would include my day pack. Well, I overpacked. When you have more space, you add more stuff. I’ve gotten rid of a lot of unneeded clothing along the way. I typically go layout everything every three months and assess what I’ve been using or not using. My rule is, if I haven’t used it in 60 to 90 days, I toss it. Most simple items can be bought wherever you’re at. 

S-Biners are great to have. You hang them on your backpack. They don’t take up much space, they’re lightweight and make it easy to hang your bag when you need to. They’re so small and convenient. 

Bucky Pratt backpack

Above: Size matters!  Small is great for a day pack but a 65-liter main pack will hold the gear and clothing needed for extended durations.

Packing cubes have been a game-changer. They’re fabric cubes that keep everything in place. I wish I would have had them in the military for my rucksack and sea bags. I recall numerous times going through my rucksack looking to the bottom right corner where I always kept extra whatever, but for some reason the item wasn’t in that spot. You think you know where it’s at because you always pack your bag the same. Then, you tear your bag apart. I don’t know about you, but I hated that in the military. Packing cubes are especially nice if you are staying in hostels, if you’re in a dark room, and you don’t want to use a light because you’re trying to be courteous. 

Bucky Pratt layoutAbove: Layout of the main pack contents, which includes everything necessary to reset at the end of the day and sustain months of adventure.  A detailed breakdown of all the contents can be found at: grmlnglobal.com.

The bag I have is a top, front, and bottom load. A little bit more vulnerable in some ways, but the convenience of it is important to me. I also pack braided steel cable with me. A lot of times if I’m staying in a hostel where they don’t have lockers, or I’m on a train, I’ll take that and I’ll loop it through my backpack to avoid anyone easily snagging my bag when I’m out or asleep. 

Before arriving in a new country, what are the steps you take?

Bucky Pratt: I do preparation ahead of time before I arrive to a new place. I always look up the location of the embassy or consulate. Get a local SIM card. Make a reservation at an accommodation, even if it’s just for one night. I’d rather know where I’m going for one night than show up and have no clue. I use an offline GPS map app to mark locations — that way if I can’t get a SIM card, at least I have the locations marked and I can just look at the map and figure out my route to get there. Figure out where the closest medical facility is. Look up local news, crime rates, etc. When I arrive to an accommodation, I assess the area. That includes entry/exit points of the building, security cameras, fire exits, is there staff on duty 24/7, etc. After checking in, I try to make a habit of conducting an expanding square around the accommodation. 

Have you ever changed your mind about staying at a shady place?

Bucky Pratt: Yeah. There’s been times I’ve rolled up and checked around and decided it wasn’t for me. But also, when I’m doing preparation, like the cost of a place will say a lot. Now it’s not always this way, but if it’s a $3/night hostel, the chances of it being a shady place with easy access goes up. If there is a place with a higher price, I’ll pay a couple extra bucks to stay somewhere nice. But yeah, I’ll move out of area that rubs me the wrong way. Location is a big thing — if it’s off the beaten path or it’s in a spot that’s weird to get to, those are things that will make me find a different location. The area has a lot to do with it.

Bucky Pratt divingAbove: Diving in the Gulf of Thailand.

Another thing is the staff. If something about the staff seems off, I might change my mind about where I am staying. There have been places with signs of forced entry into the room. I stayed at this hotel in Cairo, and the door to my room looked like it had been broken into more than a few times. That place made me a little uncomfortable, but my friends picked it and I was not about to ask them to rebook. I just made sure to not leave anything of value in my room while I was gone. I usually used steel cable to secure my big bag inside of a wall cabinet. Was it super secure? No, but a slight deterrent.

After spending over a year abroad living out of your backpack, what items will you change or add on your next trip?

Bucky Pratt: I will add a couple more items to my medical kit, such as QuikClot, a quality poncho, lock pick set, counter-custody items, and a high-viz panel. You just never know when you’ll need something to get out of a sticky situation. I will also pack less overall. It’s pretty easy to get stuff anywhere in the world. It might not be the highest quality, but it’ll do the trick in a pinch.

Looking back, is there anything you think you should have added to your planning process?

Bucky Pratt: I would have planned to do less. After the first 14 countries, I was really burned out, moving too fast. Feeling rushed is not fun and you miss out on the good stuff. By slowing down you get to see more of the country you’re in. It also brings down costs a little due to less transportation cost.

Bucky Pratt divingAbove: Exploring the depths of the Andaman Sea.  

You’re out there in the great wide world roughing it. What are your thoughts about how average people might react taking on this kind of challenge?

Bucky Pratt: What a lot of people in society lack is challenge. Traveling like this, for me, is the kind of challenge that is meaningful. I like living out of a backpack and having very little. I enjoy exploring new places. I may be slightly uncomfortable, or in an adverse location, but it also makes me feel more alive than ever. It’s the closest I’m getting to having the adrenaline and the joys of past experiences, and I have made it a part of my road to recovery. After all my planning, it all comes together. It’s inspiring me to open more doors, you know, I don’t want to be held back. I want the rest of my life to be a better story than what preceded it.

Have you made any meaningful connections during your travels?

Bucky Pratt: That’s the interesting thing about traveling. You make connections quickly. It’s very reminiscent of being in the military in that way, because you’re able to make these strong connections in a short time. Not that I still stay in touch with a lot of people, but there are a few people that I have and will continue to stay in touch with. And sometimes as much as I like to say I would rather avoid people, life really does come down to connections. Companionship, not in an intimate way, just companionship. What I’ve learned and experienced is so valuable and mind-opening. Especially today where people aren’t communicating as freely as previous years.

Bucky Pratt travelingAbove: Bucky stands with friends next to a retired scientist in Vattakanal, India. The gentleman kindly invited Bucky and his companions into his home for coffee and conversation.

Is there anything else you would like to pass along to anyone reading this?

Bucky Pratt: I would tell people, just be open-minded and be willing to try new things. I have to say this quote. It’s by Pico Iyer: “We travel, initially, to lose ourselves; and we travel, next, to find ourselves. We travel to open our hearts and eyes and learn more about the world than our newspapers will accommodate. We travel to bring what little we can, in our ignorance and knowledge, to those parts of the globe whose riches are differently dispersed. And we travel, in essence, to become young fools again — to slow time down and get taken in, and fall in love once more.”

I feel like we need to try slowing down. Life does not need to be as busy and hectic as it’s made out to be. Screw the rat race, man. Travel should be a thing where you slow down smell the roses. And I don’t know, I feel like it’s just so built into our DNA to move around. The instinct to explore and see what’s over the next hill. I just tell people, you know, find something, and go for it. Don’t be scared of the unknown, instead embrace the fear of the unknown and dive in. Growth is found in the uncomfortable situations. 

Bucky Pratt on a trainAbove: Watching the ground get further away while crossing the Goteik viaduct while en route to Mandalay from Hsipaw, Myanmar.

Final Thoughts

Selling off the majority of your worldly possessions to backpack the globe may or may not be for you. But the lessons learned are applicable to almost anyone, almost anywhere. They’re tried, tested, and confirmed across geographic, cultural, and socioeconomic borders. Bucky can be found on Instagram under the handle @grmln_global for more advice and introspection from around the world.  

Photos Courtesy of Bucky Pratt and Alexandra Vautin (@alvautin.media)


MORE SPOTLIGHTS AND GEAR ON OFFGRID


What If You’re Stuck in a Country Consumed by Political Turmoil

It’s 2021 and many travel restrictions have lifted, offering people the opportunity to finally vacation internationally or visit other countries for business. Although it may have seemed like COVID was the only big concern when considering foreign travel, political turmoil can be just as contagious, unpredictable, and deadly as a conventional disease. Whether it’s the 8888 Uprising in Burma, 2016 attempted coup in Turkey, or recent presidential assassination in Haiti, situations can often unfold with little to no ability to estimate how it’ll impact national stability or treatment of foreigners.

Despite whatever planning you may have thought was adequate and thorough, your overseas travel may put you in the wrong place at the wrong time with only local resources to assist you in seeking safe haven. If you were stuck in a country that was suddenly reduced to chaos and the political rhetoric on the ground shifted blame to people of your nationality, how would you deal with potentially being labeled as a threat to the local government? Risking capture could result in interrogation, imprisonment, or even death. 


Situation Type: Traveling Abroad
Your Crew: Yourself
Location: Southeast Asia
Season: Autumn
Weather: Humid; high 88 degrees F; low 63 degrees F


The Scenario:

The Setup: You take a trip to Southeast Asia, a region you’ve traveled to many times in the past, to visit a plant that manufactures goods for your company. You plan to spend a few days visiting with your associates there, but you only have a marginal understanding of the local language, culture, laws, and key facilities, such as the American embassy. Protests have been frequent in the area during the last few weeks, and most have culminated in a few arrests before crowds were dispersed by police. This time feels different. Over the next few days, you begin to worry as police presence and the size of the protests seem to be escalating. The national news is continually blaming Western influence for the corruption and continued civil unrest. As if the guilt by association couldn’t get much worse, you’re also informed that all foreign diplomats are in the process of being expelled, embassies are being forced to close, and all foreigners — particularly Americans — are being explicitly named as subversives by the government.

The Complication: You wake up a couple days before your flight home to the sound of gunshots outside your hotel. Peeking out your window, you can see a column of military vehicles moving down the street, with uniformed troops marching alongside. Citizens are fleeing in fear. You turn on the TV, and the American news channel in your hotel room is saying that protests have morphed into an attempted coup that was crushed by the government. In response, the government is now detaining and questioning any foreigners.

After speaking with a few other Americans in your hotel, you learn that the government is intermittently shutting down internet access, similar to what went on during the Arab Spring and more recently in Myanmar. You’re also informed that secret police are beginning to monitor hotels for foreigners, and that access to the airport has been compromised by a military blockade. As an American, you fear your passport may put you in jeopardy. The prison conditions are terrible, and you’re aware that many people have been incarcerated in this country indefinitely without even having a trial. 

What do you do? Who can you call? Do you have any rights whatsoever? The language barrier proves an even greater obstacle to navigate. What steps can you take to explain the situation believably and receive assistance from family, the State Department, or anyone else who can help you out? We’ve asked security expert Danny Pritbor as well as international media correspondent Miles Vining for their recommendations on how to deal with the situation.

Years ago, a mentor and longtime friend shared a quote that stuck with me throughout my years of service: “Movement without observation equals death.” At the time, the context was in reference to a low-light firearms course, where he was explaining the constant need for situational awareness. To be effective in the tactical environment, you need to process and prioritize data rapidly — in other words, stay “switched on.” As my career progressed, and the areas of operations shifted from domestic to international, I realized the saying couldn’t be truer. But based on my experiences, I’m going to add to the quote, “Movement without observation and preparation equals death.” I, along with countless others serving in operational roles, often in hostile environments, have learned some hard lessons, usually after the action takes place, and many times after lives are lost.


Security Expert Danny Pritbor’s Approach

Preparation

Prior to an overseas trip, I conduct a risk assessment. Using open-source satellite imagery, I get an overview of the area. First, I locate my hotel, the airport, and worksite. Secondly, I start to identify where my friendly locations are, like the U.S. Embassy or allied embassies. Other key locations are hospitals, alternate airports, or maritime ports. 

I identify my primary routes and secondary routes to frequently traveled locations. I research information on activities such as crime, terrorist actions, and government/civil unrest. My focus is initially on the city or town I’ll be traveling to, then working outward to the provinces and country. I pay close attention to the entire region as well; neighboring countries may have turmoil that can bleed over and affect the area of travel. By taking these steps, I establish where and when these significant acts are taking place and pinpoint the highest risk. Then, I can take steps to mitigate the risk. 

For example, I advised a group of college-aged individuals who would be traveling through parts of North Africa. They wanted to take the train, which was the common mode of transportation. There was a low to moderate threat of terrorist activity in the region. After the group attended our travel security course, they quickly understood that the train would make them vulnerable to “time and place predictability” as well as place them in a crowded environment where women are often sexually assaulted. Because they understood the risk, they developed an alternate plan which allowed for greater flexibility in how and when they traveled.

Now that there’s an understanding of the risks and situational awareness of the environment, I develop what’s called a “base monitored movement plan.” It’s pretty simple: I have someone back home who is my base monitor. I share my communications and travel plans with them. For example, I’ll check in every 24 hours at 6 p.m. local time on primary communications, which I’ll have listed as a text from my cell phone (alternate is an email; contingency is satellite text via Garmin inReach Explorer+). 

For any missed check-ins, I establish a shorter window. If I miss my 6 p.m. check-in, I attempt again as soon as possible; but if it’s midnight with no contact, my base monitor will need to consider calling the listed emergency contacts of the area I have listed in the plan. When civil unrest takes place, airports are the first to shut down. Haiti is the prime example of this and Egypt during the Arab Spring. I build options for alternate means of departures from the country. Along with my alternate communications plan, I take into consideration establishing evacuation plans which include air, land, and sea (or other body of water) options. 

What I typically do is have a pro word — a shorthand procedure word representing a predetermined meaning — designated for each city and/or evacuation plan. Should I need to affect a specific plan, I’ll send the pro word to my base monitor, and they know which plan is in effect. That way I keep my travel plans off communications.

What If You're Stuck in a Country Consumed by Political Turmoil

As a traveler, I carry two lines of gear. In principle, each line consists of the following categories: medical, communications, and personal defense. I add to these, but don’t omit any of the three. This system has served me and others well by ensuring an overlap of these critical items. If I were considered a resident or living abroad, I’d expand my lines of gear to a third (vehicle) and even a fourth (residence) line. Important note: the lines shouldn’t appear military/tactical, so leave the MOLLE and Velcro-covered bags at home. 

The first line is carried on my body. For medical, I carry a pressure bandage, usually a 4-inch Israeli bandage, stripped out of the package. I remove it from the primary marked packaging to give it a sterile look (no government markings) to avoid any questioning should my bags get searched. The bandage is packaged in a second, clear unmarked wrapper to keep it clean. I also carry a CAT Tourniquet in a non-tactical color (i.e. orange). Both these items are carried in an ankle med kit and/or cargo pockets. 

My primary form of communication is my cell phone. On it, I have my navigation and various communication applications. These apps require cell signal or Wi-Fi. Many of the navigation apps can be used offline, without cellular signal. (We could go down a rabbit hole with digital security, so that’ll be left for another time.) 

Carrying weapons abroad is always tricky. Personal defense gear will have to be a personal decision; choose items that can be explained and have a plan to do so. I try to stay within the law of the land, making every attempt to avoid scrutiny when crossing the border. I carry a SureFire Tactician flashlight and often opt to travel without my name-brand fixed blades. Once on the ground, I’ve been known to head over to a night market or hardware store for items such as a screwdriver or paring knife. I make a sheath out of cardboard, duct tape, and string (for a lanyard). These items can be disposed of in a hurry, or if questioned, I can provide a reasonable explanation as to why I have the items. The bottom line is I have a plan for personal defense. 

It’s important to note, I discreetly stash my passport in my first line. This is just in case I get separated from my second line/go-bag. During stressful situations people have been known to leave go-bags behind. I usually bring emergency cash ($2K to $5K) and/or items that can be used to barter with. Credit cards will not be useful during lawlessness and disorder. These items are hidden away in my first line.

My second line is a medium-sized backpack or messenger. I carry additional medical, communications, and items for personal defense. For medical, a full-sized individual first aid kit (IFAK) along with a booboo kit (Band-Aids and over-the-counter meds). Communications consists of Garmin inReach Explorer+ (satellite texting unit), spare batteries, charging cables, and 20,000 mAh (minimum) external battery pack. Additionally, I have a couple of headlamps, a spare flashlight, batteries, snacks, baby wipes, gloves, water purification tablets, copies of my passport/documents, compass, and rain gear.

An often-overlooked aspect of foreign travel is “denying evidence.” Understand that your social media footprint provides a great deal of information about who you are, what you do for a living, and where you stand politically and religiously. If you’re detained by the local authorities, and questioned about why you’re there and who you work for, what will they find on your social media feed? Many cultures operate on what is called a “shame and honor” system. Will your feed depict you as an honorable person? I want my social media to support my reasons for being there. 

If questioned about who I am and what I’m doing there, I should be able to provide a short, legitimate statement (SLS). For example, “I work in the textile industry, and I am visiting companies A, B, C, regarding our manufacturing needs.” If I’m in the textile business, then my feed should reflect that. No political statements, pictures of the wild night of partying, provocative behavior, and statements that would be considered disrespectful to the local religion. I’m mindful that I’m in their country and U.S. civil rights no longer apply. In other words, I have a solid “backstop” and show that I’m honorable.

On Site

If my business requires multiple trips to a location, I work toward improving my initial plans. Once on the ground, I hone in on the patterns of life: what government officials dress like, what the checkpoints look like, where the checkpoints are located, traffic patterns, interactions between locals, just the day-to-day routines. The purpose is to determine what “right” looks like, so I know what “wrong” looks like. I build my network of strategic relationships, determining which locals can be of assistance, especially should I need to implement an evacuation plan or need a safe house. 

Perhaps my contacts in shipping at the textile factory can assist with a water evacuation via the port if necessary or a trusted official can help me lay low for bit. I work to make sure the evacuation plans developed back home are a reality on the ground. This will require familiarization of routes and scouting key areas. As my network of strategic relationships expand, I work to develop additional emergency communications plans and possibly implement a mesh network such as GoTenna Pro or similar. 

If I’m located near an embassy, I arrange a meeting with the Regional Security Officer to introduce myself and explain my travel and/or company’s purpose. Just as with the local relationships I mentioned, I work on building relationships with the embassy staff to get invited to functions and stay informed. 

Don’t ignore the danger signs! There’s usually a buildup to civil unrest and critical incidents. If you have your head on right and paying attention, you should be able to make your exit prior to any major shutdowns or disruptions. If you find yourself pinned down in your hotel room or somewhere in the “open,” you need to determine the best option based on the information on the ground. Remember, movement without observation and preparation equals death.

In the tactical community, there’s a great deal of emphasis on the hard skills, like various shooting and combative programs. There’s nothing wrong with having these skillsets, but keep in mind hard skills will be used after the “bang” takes place. For today’s world traveler, there should be an equal amount of time dedicated to honing soft skills, which focuses on mitigating risk and avoidance. A few of the topics to study are: Situational Awareness, Medical/TCCC, Surveillance Detection, Active Shooter Response, Security Driving, Actions on Contact, Digital Security, Building Risk Assessments, and Base Monitored Movement plans. Learn more about how to train for these in my author bio at the end of the article.


International Media Correspondent Miles Vining’s Approach

Preparation

If knowledge is the lightest piece of gear one could put in their travel bag, then interpersonal communication skills has to be the second lightest. The most important point I’d like to stress is that the crisis prompt is essentially a man-made problem that requires human solutions. If you can’t build tangible relationships and connect with other people on a personal level, no amount of survival gadgets are going to get you out of a bind of this magnitude in a foreign country.

One thing we shouldn’t fool ourselves with is being some sort of Jason Bourne or James Bond figure who sneaks through the shadows of a foreign locale. Looking to historical precedent, it needs to be pointed out that for many of the great “Western” explorers who have conquered Everest (Edmond Hillary), crossed the Empty Quarter of the Arabian Peninsula (Wilfred Thesiger), or ran humanitarian missions into war-torn Burma and Syria (David Eubank), there has always been an equally competent or even more ambitious local counterpart/guide who has helped to navigate the human and terrain environment. This is why every successful news crew in the world has behind-the-scenes “fixers” whenever they go into foreign countries.

So, when it comes time to deal with a crisis, don’t think for one second that you won’t need the assistance of the local populace. In fact, to not take local cooperation into account is to doom yourself to failure. Whether it’s an actual guide, a driver getting you across the city, a shopkeeper to provide you with food and water, or a friendly translator, you’re going to have to negotiate, barter, explain, and even beg with people who don’t share your language, nationality, religion, or values. How successful you are at this process could mean the difference between going to a foreign jail or going home.

Gear

For communications, I usually want to have several types of data and cellular service. Ideally, I have a local SIM card, an international SIM card, and preferably two cell phones. One phone I like to call my “dirty” phone, where I download and interface with all the host countries’ applications and registrations. The other one, my “clean” one, I try to keep separate with my personal information, my more confidential calls, etc. Beyond cellular phones, some very good devices that exist are satellite pagers where I can get GPS coordinates, send SMS messages via satellite, and even push preset emergency messages to designated recipients. Spot X is one such company that has very economical packages. For a full communications capability, I no longer need to lug around a bulky Pelican case with the ubiquitous folding antenna sat phones that barely work half the time. SatSleeve from Thuraya is a very compact clip-on device that simply connects to my iPhone or Android device via Bluetooth. But with these two types of devices, I need to take into account the fact that, if I’m held in a foreign country already suspicious of my intentions, finding unregistered satellite communications technology in my luggage is a solid indication that I’m some sort of spy.

What If You're Stuck in a Country Consumed by Political Turmoil

In regards to more gear, I like to be as efficient and self-sufficient as possible. My electronics need to be compatible with the host country’s outlets and voltage; if I can power them myself via solar chargers that’s a plus. I like to bring a repair kit consisting of Shoe-Goo, gaffer’s tape, and a sewing kit to fix small tears and issues that might come up. But much more important than gear, I need to realize what I have, and be able to replace these capabilities in-country with local amenities. I should be browsing local stores to see what might work better or is equal in comparison to the kit I’m bringing in. Amazon isn’t going to be there for me when I need it the most. I don’t want to be a hostage to my equipment, and I need to adapt when items fail.

With communications, I have to assume that everything I’m transmitting is being bugged, censored, or recorded some way or another. Applications such as Signal are great, but it doesn’t make a difference if the host country is able to covertly download software to your phone that monitors your keystrokes. Prearranged brevity codes are good to develop with family members and friends, but they have to be kept simple and dummy proof. For example, one brevity code I’ve used with my spouse is in referencing the third floor of our apartment if I were to get into a bind, but still have communications. Of course, our apartment doesn’t have a third floor, it only has two, but that’s the point. I can call her and say, “Would you mind looking through my hockey sticks in the third-floor storage room,” in response she could make up the flow of the conversation, but instantly realize that something is very wrong in my part of the world.

On-Site

Whenever I’m in a new location overseas, I need to try and seek out whatever environment I’m in, both the physical and the human terrain map. For the human terrain, I want to know who is in the area every day. The security folks, restaurant employees, gym employees, and receptionists. Can I establish a rapport, even a friendship that might be able to help me? Knowing my physical environment is critical as well. What roads, pathways, buildings, and structures show up on maps that don’t exist anymore, and vice versa. Offline mapping applications such as Maps.Me, or OsmAnd are fantastic when the network is down, but a thorough scouting should still be in order. On one occasion when I was climbing a hill in China, I came cross a patchwork of small-gauge power lines anchored on steel poles only knee-high. Sure, I could low crawl underneath them, but that wouldn’t have been an efficient route if I needed to get over that hill in a hurry with gear. Satellite images of the hill showed a bare surface.

When I’m staying in an unfamiliar sleeping location, I want to consolidate my belongings in a way that still allows me to efficiently get to them and use them, but also so that I can easily work from them. I can’t live in a state of hyper-preparedness, but I also don’t want to get caught with all my overseas worldly belongings littered across a hotel room. What I try to do is minimize the number of places where I keep my belongings. I pick three or four locations in a room and stick to them — the closet, the bathroom, my bedside table, and maybe a desk. I use my existing bags as organizers and wardrobes for my belongings.

Having a designated go-bag is definitely nice, but let’s keep things in perspective here. I’m in a foreign country, I need all my belongings. I don’t want to just survive; I want to thrive with all my equipment. Maybe I bounce out of that hotel room with my sweet go-bag and end up having to hunker down somewhere in-country for weeks at a time because the borders are closed due to the volatile political situation. If I have the liberty of 20 to 30 minutes in my room, wouldn’t I have wanted to at least attempt to gather the rest of my belongings, which should’ve only been in several locations to begin with?

That being said, I need to come up with a realistic evasion logistical plan. If I’m starting with no time at all, I can only leave with what I have on my person. That should be my passport (and a small laminated copy thereof in another location on my body), shoes, what I’m wearing, an ability to see at night, whether that’s a headlamp or a handheld light (which also works nicely as a blunt force weapon), my mobile device and a way to charge it, and a jacket (which can double as a blanket). This sounds simple, but let us imagine a scenario where you’re in your hotel or around the corner from it, and you cannot access your room due to a hostile takeover, a police barricade, or an angry mob rampaging and looking for foreigners (CWO Bryan Ellis was killed in this manner during the 1979 U.S. embassy riots in Islamabad).

Our second time slot is going to be that several-minute window where we can get our go-bag, throw a couple extra necessities in, and scram out the door. Now, we have a more nuanced approach to how we can live out of that bag for a limited period of time.

Our third time slot will be half an hour to perhaps an hour. You know a crisis is ongoing and you have to leave. If we can leave with all our belongings, let’s try for that. If we’re limited to our go-bag and maybe a secondary small bag, that works too. Now we can prioritize what we can jettison or keep when it comes to space. This would also be a good time to organize bags on priority, starting with what’s on your person first. If you have to jettison all your bags, what do you need to ensure stays with you? If you have to jettison one or two, which ones are they going to be, based on priority? We probably don’t want to chuck our laptop, power banks, and hard drives, but that suitcase with souvenirs, extra clothes, or items we can probably get locally anyway could probably go.

Crisis

When I’m in a foreign country that might be third-world, totalitarian governed, and even at peace, I’m working with the notion that everyone I meet already assumes I’m a spy, an agent, or some kind of intelligence officer for the United States. I’ll actually never be able to rid myself of this assumption. But I do have the ability to either lessen the spy bias or increase it. By owning or carrying tactical items — even something as innocent as a C-A-T tourniquet, for example — the assumption of being an agent has been heightened. If I try not to lie and try to be honest with authorities, the spy assumption might be relaxed. How I present myself through my physical belongings, demeanor, attitude, and actions will bear a tremendous amount of weight in the minds of those whose authority will determine whether I can get on a plane back home or rot in an overcrowded jail. Now isn’t the time to be coming up with a cover identity or a supposed origin story. 

When I’m questioned, I want to stick to the facts. I don’t need to be opining about which side I support in the country, what I think about the deteriorating situation, or the United States’ role in the mix. What’s my business, what I am doing, what items I’m carrying, where I want to go, and how I want to leave.

Bribes are an incredibly tough subject overseas. They’re just as likely to get me in trouble as they’re able to get me out of trouble. Especially with bribing official authorities, because that adds more fuel to my case of being a no-good foreigner in someone else’s country. If I were to attempt a bribe, I’d try to relegate it to small, tangible actions that can be completed soon and in my vicinity — bribing a guard to open a gate, a ticket manager to change a ticket. I’m in no position to make open-ended, complicated, behind-the-scenes negotiated agreements that’ll lead to my release. This isn’t my turf, and I don’t know the human terrain with the right relationships in positions of power. What kind of language I use is especially key as well. Many authorities who take in bribes regularly don’t like to refer to it in such crass terms. Instead of saying, “Can I pay you to open this gate,” maybe try, “I would like to give you a bonus for your hard work,” or “If you can help me with something, I can monetarily return the favor.” An outright bribe of “I’ll pay you a certain amount to do this for me” might end up insulting someone severely. Put on your best thinking shoes and work some diplomacy.

When looking at international organizations for help or escaping to neighboring countries, I’ll have to tap into pre-existing networks somehow. There are numerous emergency travel insurance companies out there that work in ways that can be very beneficial. This doesn’t mean they’ll be fast-roping into your compound with an armed extraction team, but it does mean they might be able to arrange plane tickets with travel agencies they’re friendly with, or have folks in those countries come and provide places to stay or advice. Global Rescue and Ripcord are two such companies, but there are several out there.


Conclusion

The key to any of these situations is going to be your intuition and people skills. Work through some of these scenarios with an assumption of being stripped of everything you know apart from your clothes, then revisit how you would handle that situation. The gear is great, but your interpersonal skills need to be one step ahead. Stay cool, calm, and collected, build up your sources, verify your news, act with confidence, and go with your intuition.

Pay attention to escalating problems in any area you plan to visit. A population’s confusion and overall disposition about a situation can be easily exacerbated by mass media and sudden turmoil. Check the U.S. State Department website for travel advisories prior to venturing abroad. Having redundant forms of communication to relay information to anyone back home, multiple escape routes, and friendly local contacts are just a few necessities that could mean the difference between survival and incarceration.

No one needs to know anything about you other than what you look like to form inaccurate and dangerous assessments that could put your life in danger. Although the reality may be that regional unrest has nothing to do with you personally, the perception on the ground may be that it does. Don’t assume this situation is only specific to other countries. You may have to apply these lessons to a domestic situation if civil stability continues to decline.

[Editor’s Note: Illustrations by Cassandra Dale.]


About the Authors

danny pritborDanny Pritbor, director and owner of Firebase Combat Studies Group, currently serves as a Department of Defense contractor. Danny’s career spans over 29 years with service as a U.S. Marine, law enforcement SWAT officer, Department of Energy and Department of State contractor, federal agent, and private security consultant. He’s served worldwide in various war zones and high-threat areas. His company partnered with Panoplia to develop a nine-hour, online training program called Soft Skills and Tactics. It consists of three parts, nine lessons with 45 topics covered. In conjunction with the online course, Firebase offers a two-day security training program that consists of lecture, hands-on, and a field training exercise with stations that push participants to take charge, make decisions, and problem solve. For more information on the online SST program, please visit to panoplia.org. You can also reach Danny at firebasecsg.com.

miles vining

Miles Vining spent his childhood and teenage years growing up in Thailand, Burma, and Malaysia, returning to the region after his service in the Marines to work with an international relief group that works in conflict zones in Iraq, Syria, and Sudan. He also worked in digital media with a local Afghan company in Kabul. Beyond RECOIL, his work has appeared in Small Arms Review, The Firearm Blog, the TFB TV YouTube channel, and Strife Blog. Currently, he’s the editor of Silah Report, an online resource group focused on researching historical and contemporary small arms and light weapons from the Middle East and Central Asian regions. Learn more at www.silahreport.com.


MORE SCENARIOS TO CONSIDER: